| Causality and the Interpretation of Epidemiologic Evidence Michael Kundi Institute of Environmental Health, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Austria Abstract
There is an ongoing debate regarding how and when an agent's or determinant's impact can be interpreted as causation with respect to some target disease. The so-called criteria of causation, originating from the seminal work of Sir Austin Bradford Hill and Mervyn Susser, are often schematically applied disregarding the fact that they were meant neither as criteria nor as a checklist for attributing to a hazard the potential of disease causation. Furthermore, there is a tendency to misinterpret the lack of evidence for causation as evidence for lack of a causal relation. There are no criteria in the strict sense for the assessment of evidence concerning an agent's or determinant's propensity to cause a disease, nor are there criteria to dismiss the notion of causation. Rather, there is a discursive process of conjecture and refutation. In this commentary, I propose a dialogue approach for the assessment of an agent or determinant. Starting from epidemiologic evidence, four issues need to be addressed: temporal relation, association, environmental equivalence, and population equivalence. If there are no valid counterarguments, a factor is attributed the potential of disease causation. More often than not, there will be insufficient evidence from epidemiologic studies. In these cases, other evidence can be used instead that increases or decreases confidence in a factor being causally related to a disease. Even though every verdict of causation is provisional, action must not be postponed until better evidence is available if our present knowledge appears to demand immediate measures for health protection. Key words: causality, epidemiology. Environ Health Perspect 114:969–974 (2006) . doi:10.1289/ehp.8297 available via http://dx.doi.org/ [Online 27 March 2006]
Address correspondence to M. Kundi, Institute of Environmental Health, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Kinderspitalgasse 15, 1095 Vienna, Austria. Telephone: 43-1-4277-64726. Fax: 43-1-4277-9647. E-mail: Michael.Kundi@meduniwien.ac.at The author declares he has no competing financial interests. Received 8 May 2005 ; accepted 27 March 2006.
The full version of this article is available for free in HTML or PDF formats. |
