Manuscript received 27 April 1995; manuscript accepted 15 March 1996.
Introduction
In 1992, a research group at the Department of Growth and Reproduction, the National University Hospital (Rigshospitalet), and the Panum Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark, published in the British Medical Journal a metaanalysis of the data from the international literature that revealed a significant decrease in sperm concentration and semen volume in otherwise normal men over the period 1938 to 1990. During the same time period, the incidence of testicular cancer had markedly increased in many countries. These and other observations provided a clue that this apparent decline in male reproductive health might be caused by some common environmental factors. It was recognized that similar abnormalities of the male reproductive system were caused by administration of estrogens during pregnancy in humans and experimental animals; therefore, a hypothesis was put forward that environmental chemicals having estrogenic effects were contributing agents. In particular, it was suggested that fetal exposure to an excess of estrogenic compounds was a key risk factor.
After an intense public debate in the Danish news media on the possible role of environmental chemicals, such as pesticides, detergents, plasticizers, and other industrial chemicals, the Danish Environmental Protection Agency (DEPA) of the Ministry of Environment and Energy in September 1994 decided to support the preparation of a review summarizing the current knowledge on male reproductive disorders and environmental chemicals with estrogenic effects. In addition, the review was to identify gaps in knowledge and address research needs and requirements in order for researchers to perform adequate risk assessments. The DEPA asked Professor Niels E. Skakkebæk, Department of Growth and Reproduction at the National University Hospital and John Chr. Larsen, Division Head, Institute of Toxicology at the Danish National Food Agency to prepare the report. The project received additional financial support from the Ministry of Health through its National Research Centre for Environmental Medicine.
Dr. Jorma Toppari, Departments of Pediatrics and Physiology, University of Turku, Finland, prepared a draft of the report. This draft was then discussed by a group of Danish and international experts invited to a one-week workshop that was held at Rigshospitalet in Copenhagen, January 23-27, 1995. The participants who are the authors of the present publication actively contributed to the endeavor both during the workshop and afterward. The final manuscript was edited by Jorma Toppari together with Niels E. Skakkebæk and John Chr. Larsen. The present review is a revised version of the official report (1), which was printed by the Danish Ministry of Environment and Energy mainly for circulation in Denmark.
The review addresses the possible effects of environmental chemicals known to possess estrogenic activity on male reproductive health. The term xenoestrogen is often used for such compounds, whereas the term synthetic estrogens refers to medical drugs mainly used for contraception and treatment of various diseases.
A number of other environmental chemicals have been implicated as environmental hormones or endocrine disruptors. Although not shown (and in many instances not adequately tested) to possess direct estrogenic activity, some of these compounds may in some cases also affect male reproduction. The mechanisms of action are not known in detail but they may involve, for example, antiandrogenic activity; modulatory effects on enzymes controlling sex hormone metabolism; or direct influence on the hormone-producing organs such as the thyroid gland, pituitary gland, and adrenal glands. These compounds may also affect estrogen levels through indirect feedback mechanisms.
The authors are well aware that the decline in semen quality and the increase in the incidence of testicular cancer may be caused by many other environmental, life-style, or genetic factors. For example, some chemicals that are now known as occupational toxicants were shown to affect the semen quality of the workers through a toxic action on the gonads, without any apparent estrogenic effects. Such toxic effects are not the object of the present report, but should be kept in mind in any consideration or scientific investigation of the adverse effects of environmental chemicals on male reproductive health.
Secular Trends in the Incidence of Male Reproductive Disorders
Trends in Semen Quality
Several reports in the literature have suggested a possible decline in human semen quality during the last 50 to 60 years (2-4). However, most of these reports were based on data from men attending infertility clinics or from very selected groups of fertile men and, therefore, the decline in sperm counts was presumed just to reflect changes in the policy of infertility treatment or a bias in selection of patients rather than a true biological phenomenon. A systematic metaanalysis of 61 studies that included 14,947 normal men revealed a significant decrease in sperm concentration (113 million/ml vs 66 million/ml; Figure 1) and semen volume (3.40 ml vs 2.75 ml) over the period of 1938 to 1990 (5). This report stimulated extensive discussion and some criticisms on the basis of possible technical errors and known limitations of metaanalysis (6,7). Carlsen and co-workers responded to these criticisms (8). Although the data for 1970 to 1990 were compatible with a decrease as well as with no change or an increase in semen quality, the cautious general conclusion was that a real decline occurred during the 50-year period (9). The findings of Carlsen et al. (5) were also compared (6) to those of MacLeod and Wang (10) from the United States. This comparison is not relevant, however, because the metaanalysis was based on semen analyses of normal men, whereas the American study examined men who were clients of an infertility clinic.
Figure 1. Linear regression of mean sperm density reported in 61 publications (represented by circles the area of which is proportional to the logarithm of the number of subjects in the study), each weighted according to number of subjects, 1938-1990. The figure is based on the data reported by Carlsen et al. (5). A corresponding figure in that paper was incomplete.
The metaanalysis of Carlsen et al. (5) prompted several laboratories to evaluate their data on the quality of semen obtained during recent years. In a French study of 1351 healthy men volunteering for sperm donation, a 2.1% decrease in sperm concentration per year from 89 million/ml in 1973 to 60 million/ml in 1992 (
p<0.001) was found (11). Furthermore, the percentages of motile and normal spermatozoa also decreased significantly (Figure 2), whereas semen volume remained unchanged (3.8 ml). It is notable that the year of birth of the study subjects contributed significantly to the results. Multiple regression analysis (which allows for separate effects of age and calendar year at birth) showed yearly decreases of 2.6% in sperm concentration, 0.3% in motility percentage, and 0.7% in the percentage of normal spermatozoa according to the year of birth of the men (all changes,
p<0.001) (11). Similar results were obtained in a Scottish study (12) of 577 semen donors where a correlation was found between the median sperm count and the year of birth; the median sperm concentration decreased from 98 million/ml among donors born before 1959 to 78 million/ml among donors born after 1970 (
p=0.002). The total number of sperm in the ejaculate fell from 301 million to 214 million (
p=0.0005)(12). The association between declining semen quality and a more recent year of birth lends support to the concept that adverse prenatal factors may influence the sperm production capacity in adult life. Deterioration of sperm counts as well as motility among semen donor candidates during the past two decades was also observed in a smaller Belgian study (13). Ginsburg and Hardiman (14) reported a decrease in sperm concentrations (105 million/ml in 1978-1983 vs 76 million/ml in 1984-1989) of the partners of women treated for infertility and living in the Thames water supply area of London, whereas no decrease was found among those who lived in other water supply areas of London. However, the mean percentage of abnormal spermatozoa increased in all areas during the study period (18-19% vs 30-32%) (14). The data in all the studies cited above originated in individual laboratories that used consistently the same methods for semen analysis throughout the period.
The decreasing trend in semen quality may not be global. In contrast to the Paris area, no change in sperm concentration was found in the Toulouse area in France during 1977 to 1992 (15). The mean sperm count of samples from 302 healthy fertile donors was 83 million/ml (15). Furthermore, the sperm concentration in semen of Finnish men has remained unchanged between 1958 and 1992 (111 million/ml vs 124 million/ml) and is higher than elsewhere in Europe (16). It is of interest that the incidence of testicular cancer, and perhaps also hypospadias, in Finland is much lower than that in other Nordic countries (below), suggesting that these phenomena may be related in some way. The reason remains unknown, but further examination may provide important clues to the etiology of decreasing sperm quality worldwide. Urban areas (e.g., Paris) appear to have a declining trend in sperm counts, whereas rural areas (e.g., Toulouse or Finland) seem to have stable sperm concentrations in semen.
Incidence of Testicular Cancer
Testicular cancer is now the most common malignancy of young men in many countries; and although it is still rare compared to the malignant diseases most prevalent in old age, the lifetime risk of developing testicular cancer now approaches 1% in a country such as Denmark. The incidence of testicular cancer has increased for several decades (17). On the basis of data from cancer registries, increases in incidence are evident in England and Wales (18,19), Scotland (20), the Nordic and Baltic countries (21,22), Australia (23), New Zealand (24,25), and the United States (26). The observed increase has been approximately 2 to 4% per annum in men under 50 years of age (Figures 3, 4) and occurred in the same age group in which testicular cancer incidence peaks, i.e., young adults (Figure 5). Table 1 displays the changes that have occurred during the last 25 years. There are marked racial and geographic differences. For example, Denmark has a 4-fold higher incidence of testicular cancer than does nearby Finland, and Caucasians are 3-fold more susceptible to this disease than are African Americans in the United States. Nevertheless, it is obvious that there is a worldwide trend toward an increased incidence of testicular cancer as illustrated in Figures 3-5. The incidences of both seminomas and nonseminomas have increased (17). Mortality due to testicular cancer increased from the beginning of this century until the early 1970s when, because of the development of good medical treatment, mortality began to decline (17). However, we still do not know the etiology of testicular cancer and cannot therefore develop any preventive measures.
Figure 3. Secular, racial, and geographic trends in the incidence of testicular cancer, 1953-1987. Compilation of data from IARC (318-323).
Figure 4. Trends in age-standardized (world standard population) incidence rates of testicular cancer. From Adami et al. (22); reprinted with permission from Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Figure 5. Age-specific incidence of testicular cancer 1985-1989 in the Nordic countries, Poland, and former East Germany. From Adami et al. (22); reprinted with permission from Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Incidence of Cryptorchidism
Birth data from several reports have indicated a substantial increase in the incidence of cryptorchidism (maldescent of the testis). However, estimates of the prevalence of cryptorchidism obtained from different studies are difficult to compare. It is often not clear how a cryptorchid testis was defined, and inclusion of different proportions of boys with retractile testes could account for the reported differences. The sources of data used in these reports also differ considerably. The prevalence rates have varied between 0.03 and 13.4% on the basis of data from birth to 1 year of age from hospital or central registers (including different proportions of preterm babies) (27-48); 0.16 to 13.3% in surveys from school, army, etc. (36,38,49-57); and 2 to 4.7% in cohort studies based on discharge diagnosis (41,58,59). A few studies include ethnic data on non-Caucasians: birth data from India (33), Formosa (Taiwan) (38), and Korea (44) indicated prevalences of 1.6, 1.4, and 0.7% of cryptorchidism, respectively. A school survey from Nigeria (56) indicated a prevalence of 0.5%. The incidence of cryptorchidism among African Americans was reported to be only one-third that among whites (34), although another study (48) did not find a significant difference. Racial and ethnic data are pooled in most studies. Unfortunately, very few studies exist examining temporal changes in the incidence of cryptorchidism, confined to the same population and geographic areas and using an identical definition of the condition.
Discharge data from the Hospital Inpatient Enquiry from England and Wales showed that the proportion of boys undergoing orchidopexy (operation to bring the testis into the scrotum) before 15 years of age increased from 1.4% for a 1952 birth cohort to 2.9% for a 1977 birth cohort (58). However, it is not known whether this is a reflection of a true increase in the prevalence of cryptorchidism or whether a considerable number of boys with retractile testes were undergoing orchidopexy. In Scotland, the annual number of discharges of boys 0 to 14 years of age with the diagnosis of cryptorchidism also showed a substantial increase during 1961 to 1985 (41). In Denmark, the prevalence of cryptorchidism at birth in male infants weighing > 2500 g varied between 1 and 1.8% in three different data sets obtained in the late 1950s (60). School surveys suggested higher prevalence rates up to 7% during 1940 to 1966, but these figures apparently included retractile testes (55). Cohort analysis of data from the Danish National Register of Hospital In- and Outpatients, from the period 1982 to 1985, indicated an incidence of cryptorchidism of approximately 2% (59).
In a study from the late 1950s that examined more than 3500 male infants delivered in a hospital in London and followed up to 1 year of age, Scorer (31) found that the incidences of cryptorchidism at 3 months of age in boys with birth weights <2500 g and >2500 g were 1.74 and 0.91%, respectively. Scorer used very accurate definitions of the positions of testes, and therefore, this well-conducted study has served as a reference for later research. In a large study from the 1980s, comprising 7441 male infants from Oxford (47), the very same examination technique and definitions of cryptorchidism were used; the rates of cryptorchidism at the age of 3 months in boys with birth weights <2500 g and >2500 g were 5.2 and 1.61%, respectively, indicating a significant increase compared to Scorer's figures. In another study from the late 1980s composed of 6935 male infants from New York (48) (using identical study techniques and case definition), prevalence rates of cryptorchidism at the age of 3 months in boys with birth weights <2500 g and >2500 g were 1.94 and 0.91%, respectively. However, the study population was racially and ethnically heterogeneous. From these three large studies, one can conclude that there has been a significant increase in the incidence of cryptorchidism in England, but the incidence in the racially and ethnically mixed population of New York is similar to that reported in the 1950s in England.
The epidemiological data indicative of an increasing incidence of cryptorchidism are not unequivocal. This important issue necessitates large regional prospective studies in which standard criteria are adopted for an accurate description of cryptorchidism.
Incidence of Hypospadias
Birth data from several reports have indicated a substantial increase in prevalence of hypospadias (Figures 6, 7). Figures of birth prevalence of hypospadias in the world literature vary considerably--from 0.37 to 41 per 10,000 infants (61,62)--and are difficult to compare. There are several factors that may contribute to the reported differences: different levels of ascertainment, different inclusion of minor forms of hypospadias or differences in ethnical origin of the population. As reported for cryptorchidism, very few longitudinal studies confined to the same population and geographic area exist. The increasing incidence of hypospadias has been reported primarily in England and Wales (39), Hungary (63,64), Sweden (65-67), Norway (67,68) and Denmark (66,67). No increasing trend was noticed in Finland, Spain, New Zealand, Australia, or Czechoslovakia (67).
Figure 6. Prevalence of hypospadias at birth (rate per 10,000 births) in England and Wales, and Hungary. Based on data from WHO (67).
Figure 7. Prevalence of hypospadias at birth (rate per 10,000 births) in the Scandinavian countries. Based on data from WHO (67).
England and Wales. The data from England and Wales are based on the national register that includes the whole population. Analysis of the data indicated a steady increase in the prevalence of hypospadias from 7.3 per 10,000 births in 1964 to approximately 16 per 10,000 births in the early 1980s, when the number of cases stabilized (Figure 6). In 1990 the prevalence of hypospadias showed a decrease to 11.7 per 10,000.
Hungary. The Hungarian data are based on the national register of the whole population. As shown in Figure 6, there was a rapid increase in the prevalence of hypospadias from 5.5 per 10,000 births in 1964 to 23.9 per 10,000 in 1978. Since then, the prevalence of hypospadias, although fluctuating, has remained at approximately the same level.
Scandinavian Countries. The data on the incidence of hypospadias in Scandinavia (Figure 7) are all based on the national registers that include the whole populations. The Danish data from 1970 to 1981 indicated a significant increase for this period (from approximately 7.5 to 12 per 10,000 births) (66). A further increase was noticed during the period 1982 to 1988 (67). However, this increase may be difficult to interpret as a new registration system was introduced. Nevertheless, this increase was similar to that reported for the years 1970 to 1981.
The data from Sweden also indicated a marked increase in the early 1970s: prevalence of hypospadias at birth was 40% higher between 1974 and 1982 than for the period 1965 to 1968 (66,69). However, the data obtained in the earlier period could be more complete, because they included both hospital records and registry data.
Also in Norway the prevalence of hypospadias at birth increased from 7 to 8 per 10,000 births between 1967 and 1971 to 13 per 10,000 in 1973 (68). In 1988, the prevalence was 20.7 per 10,000 births (67).
Ethnic Differences. The incidence of hypospadias in the United States is higher in Caucasians than in African Americans (ratio of 1.3-3.9:1) (70-73). In British Columbia, Canada, Native Americans were reported to have a lower incidence of hypospadias than the general Caucasian population, with a ratio of 1:6.7 (74,75).
Geographic Variation. Considerable variation exists in the prevalence of hypospadias among different countries. Interestingly, some populations with a low incidence of testicular cancer (e.g., Finland) (22) have a very low prevalence of hypospadias (Figure 7). Furthermore, there seems to be considerable geographic variation in the prevalence of hypospadias within different countries (66,76).
Incidence of Male Breast Cancer
As xenoestrogens were implicated as possible factors involved in the pathogenesis of breast cancer in women (77), the trends in the incidence of this disease in males should be monitored. Male breast cancer is a rare disease; only a few studies exist on geographical and temporal trends. Ewertz et al. (78) studied the incidence of male breast cancer in four Nordic countries and found a weak increase with calendar time in Denmark (1943-1982) but no change in Finland, Norway, and Sweden over the period 1953 (1958 for Sweden) to 1982. Ewertz et al. noted a remarkable geographical trend, with Denmark having an incidence about twice that of Finland.
Summary
Semen quality has deteriorated in many countries during the last 50 years. The incidence of testicular cancer has been increasing almost invariably worldwide. Increases in the incidences of cryptorchidism and hypospadias have been observed in countries in which longitudinal studies have been performed. However, there are clear regional differences. The prevalence of male breast cancer has been rising and is higher in Denmark than in Finland.
Changes in Male Reproduction in Wildlife. Estrogenic Effects on Developing Animals
Changes in male reproduction in wildlife involve such issues as feminization, demasculinization, reduced fertility, reduced hatchability, reduced viability of offspring, impaired hormone secretion or activity, and altered sexual behavior (79). Since it is not possible to review all of the data in detail, the reader is referred to a recent workshop publication titled "Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection" (80). Many of the reproductive disorders listed above have been associated with xenoestrogenic effects on the fetus. It has usually not been possible to ascribe lowered reproductive success and signs of feminization and demasculinization in wildlife to a single agent; in these cases, chemical analyses of specimens have revealed the presence of multiple compounds, some of which are known to have hormonelike activity. There is experimental evidence that xenoestrogens act cumulatively, i.e., 10 compounds administered simultaneously, each one at 1/10 of their effective dose, resulted in a potent estrogenic response (81). Cumulative exposure to nongonadal estrogens is easily documented in male birds, amphibians, and fish by measuring plasma vitellogenin levels.
Gastropod Species
Pseudohermaphroditism or imposex-- females developing male characteristics--in marine gastropod species has been reported worldwide: the northeastern United States (82), the United Kingdom (83), Alaska (84), and Southeast Asia (85). This phenomenon is caused by tributyltin (TBT) compounds leached from marine antifouling paints used on ships, boats, and mariculture pen nets (83). Very low concentrations (1 ng/liter) of TBT-derived tin are effective in induction of imposex (83), and marine areas averaging 6 to 8 ng/liter of TBT suffer reproductive failure and local extinction due to female sterility (86). The use of TBT was restricted in the 1980s, and recovery of some species has been reported after that (87). However, imposex still remains a problem for gastropod species in several marine areas. The mechanism of action of TBT is unknown. The effect mimics that of an antiestrogen, and therefore presents an example of the drastic hormonelike effect of a xenobiotic threatening the existence of several species, even though higher species seem to be far less sensitive to TBT.
Reptiles
Lake Apopka, Florida, was extensively polluted with dicofol (86), 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2-bis(p-chlorophenyl)ethane (DDT) (and its metabolites 1,1-dichloro-2,2-bis(p-chlorophenyl)ethane [DDD], 1,1-dichloro-2,2-bis(p-chlorophenyl)ethylene [DDE] and chloro-DDT), and sulfuric acid spilled accidentally from a chemical company in 1980. Further contamination of the lake by agricultural sewage dumping has made this lake one of Florida's most polluted wetlands. A number of these pollutants are known to have estrogenic or endocrine-disrupting effects (89). The chemical spill was followed in the subsequent 3 years by a significant decline in the number of juvenile alligators, whereas alligator populations elsewhere were increasing or stable at the same time (90). The population decline was associated with reproductive disorders that were hypothesized to be caused by endocrine-disrupting xenobiotics (91). There are extensive data supporting the hypothesis (92,93): female alligators from Lake Apopka had plasma estradiol concentrations 2 times that of normal females from the control lake, Lake Woodruff. The females exhibited abnormal ovarian morphology. Likewise, in males abnormal germ cells were observed in the testes. Furthermore, Lake Apopka male alligators had abnormally small phalli. Basal and luteinizing hormone (LH)-stimulated plasma testosterone concentrations of male juvenile alligators in Lake Apopka were significantly lower than those of Lake Woodruff males, equaling those of females. The plasma estrogen concentrations of male alligators from these two lakes did not differ. However, testes from Lake Apopka alligators produced significantly more estradiol in vitro than testes from control alligators; testosterone production was similar (93). The discordance in the in vitro and in vivo findings suggests additional significant differences in steroid metabolism and liver function between the alligators from these two lakes, emphasizing the complexity of environmental influences. Reptiles have temperature-sensitive sex determination that can be altered by estrogen treatment (94). This has been demonstrated both in alligators (95) and turtles (96). The data from Lake Apopka suggested that the gonads of alligators had been permanently modified, altering steroidogenesis and inhibiting normal sexual maturation (91,97,98).
A recent study (99) has demonstrated that a number of PCB metabolites are capable of acting as synthetic estrogens. As with crocodilians, many turtles exhibit environmental sex determination so that the temperature at which the egg is incubated determines the sex of the offspring (97). Turtle eggs incubated at 26šC produce 100% males. However, if eggs incubated at a male-producing temperature are "painted" with either one of two PCB metabolites (2´,4´,6´-trichloro-4-biphenylol or 2´,3´,4´,5´-tetrachloro-4-biphenylol) sex reversal occurs as if the eggs were treated with the natural estrogen, 17ß-estradiol (99). Interestingly, if eggs are treated with a dose of both compounds (100 µg of each)--a dose that produced a small percentage of sex-reversed turtles (20 and 0%, respectively)--they act synergistically, producing sex reversal in 80% of the eggs treated. Thus, animals that should have developed as males are modified so that their internal and external morphology is that of a normal female. It is unknown if this sex reversal produces fertile adult females.
Fish
Modifications in reproductive functioning of male fish living downstream from kraft pulp mills have been well documented. For example, white sucker (Catostomis commersoni) collected from sites receiving primary effluent exhibited delayed maturation, smaller gonads, and an absence of secondary sex characteristics (100). Furthermore, these males had significantly reduced serum testosterone concentrations and dysfunctional hypothalamic control of the pituitary-gonadal axis. A similar reduction in gonad size was reported for both male and female perch (Perca fluviatilis) inhabiting sites receiving primary effluent from a kraft mill on the coast of the Gulf of Bothnia (101). The effects observed in these perch were graded along the pollution gradient (2-8 km) from the mill. Masculinization and behavioral changes of female mosquito fish (Gambusia affinis) were observed in Florida rivers downstream from paper and pulp mills (102). Laboratory studies corroborated the hypothesis that kraft mill effluents containing large amounts of the plant steroids sitosterol and stigmastanol caused the changes (103). However, the etiologic agents in paper-mill effluents have not been identified unequivocally. Other effects of paper-mill effluents on fish have been reviewed by Owens (104) and Leatherland (105).
The effect of PCB exposure on testicular function in fish also has been examined. In the Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua), testicular steroidogenesis is disrupted by dietary exposure to PCBs (106). Additionally, Freeman et al. (107) observed that cod exposed to PCBs in vivo exhibited increased metabolism of steroid hormones in vitro by kidney and liver tissues. Further, dietary exposure of juvenile males to PCBs precluded the rise in plasma testosterone concentrations associated with sexual maturity. These data suggest that PCBs modify both testicular androgen synthesis and steroid utilization/degradation in peripheral tissues. Exposure to crude oil also induced a decrease in plasma testosterone concentrations in the winter flounder, Pseudopleuronectus americanus (108).
Organochlorines have also been implicated in a number of developmental and reproductive abnormalities in fish living in the Laurentian Great Lakes of North America. Male coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) living in Lake Erie exhibit a number of abnormalities, including decreased fertility, lower plasma concentrations of gonadotropins and steroids (testosterone, 11-ketotestosterone), poor expression of secondary sex characteristics, and high precocious sexual maturation (109,110). It is unknown at this time if the above deficiencies are all related or represent different effects. It is hypothesized that some may be due to modifications of the developing embryo (organizational effects), whereas others may be due to disruptive activational events in adults.
The observation of an increased prevalence of hermaphroditism in fish in sewage treatment water (STW) lagoons in England and Wales initiated a series of studies examining environmental estrogens using a bioassay involving vitellogenin synthesis in STW-exposed rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) (111,112). Vitellogenin is produced in the liver under estrogen control by female fish for the growth of ova (113). Males produce it only after exogenous estrogen treatment (114). Vitellogenin production by male fish can therefore be used as a biomarker of environmental estrogenic activity. STW exposure of caged rainbow trout induced increases of 500- to 100,000-fold in plasma vitellogenin concentration, and males were shown to achieve vitellogenin levels almost as high as females, indicating the contamination of water by estrogenic compounds (112). In vitro studies with trout hepatocytes established a dose-response relationship with estrogen exposure and vitellogenesis (111). Using this culture system, it was demonstrated that degradation products of several alkylphenol-polyethoxylates, a major group of surfactants present in sewage, are estrogenic to fish (111). Their effect on trout hepatocytes could be blocked with an antiestrogen, Tamoxifen, demonstrating that the compounds act through the estrogen receptor. Although the estrogenic activity of individual xenobiotics was low, their effects may be additive in nature.
Birds
Feminization of gulls and terns in several locations along the Pacific coast of the United States has been associated with DDT and DDE pollution (115,116). Fry and Toone (115) demonstrated the feminizing capacity of some DDT compounds by injecting gull eggs. Feminization leads to a skewed male/female ratio, which is known to increase female-female pairing. Supernormal clutches, i.e., five to six gull eggs per nest instead of the normal three, are often laid after this type of pairing, and the fertility of the eggs is poor (117). There is some controversy as to whether feminization of males or differential mortality of males resulted in a skewed sex ratio (118). Fox (86) considered both the feminization of males and their increased mortality, when compared to females, as possible reasons for the female-female pairing and supranormal clutches in the gulls.
Mammals
Although the mechanism is unknown at this time, elevated PCBs and DDE concentrations are associated with a decrease in plasma testosterone concentrations in Dall's porpoises, Phocoenoides dalli (119). Testicular steroidogenesis in vitro has been studied in the gray seal (Halichoerus grypus) in association with exposure to methyl mercury (MeHg), cadmium (Cd), arsenic (As), selenium (Se), and a PCB mixture (Aroclor 1254). All contaminants except As and Se, stimulated testosterone synthesis in vitro from seal testicular tissue (120). The mechanism by which this stimulation occurs is unknown. Gonadal steroidogenesis is not the only target for PCBs, as a number of PCB metabolites have been shown to decrease thyroid function in vivo in the common seal, Phoca vitulina (121).
The majority of the remaining (approximately 35 individuals) endangered Florida panthers (Felis concolor coryi) exhibit a number of developmental abnormalities and reproductive defects (122). Specifically, males (n=12) showed low ejaculate volume, low sperm concentrations (3-15
106 sperm/ml semen), poor sperm motility, and a very high proportion (92.9%) of sperm with morphological abnormalities (123). Cryptorchidism (both uni- and bilateral) has increased exponentially in male cubs since 1975 so that today >90% of the male population exhibits this phenomenon (eight of nine cubs born since 1985). Male sterility may be a problem as well. Female panthers (n=3) have high body burdens of various contaminants including p,p´-DDE (5.45-57.65 mg/g lipid fresh weight), PCBs (7.32-27.06 mg/g lipid fresh weight), oxychlordane (<0.0098-2.00 mg/g lipid fresh weight) and trans-nonachlor (<0.0098-4.82 mg/g lipid fresh weight) (122). Panthers also have elevated tissue levels of mercury, methoxychlor, and other lipophilic organochlorine compounds. These contaminants are derived primarily from their major food item, the raccoon (124). The reproductive abnormalities described above were suggested to be due to the contamination of mothers by endocrine-disrupting environmental xenobiotics rather than to problems associated with inbreeding (122).
Summary
Reproductive disorders in gastropod species, reptiles, fish, birds, and mammals have been associated with environmental factors. Several of the disorders, such as sex reversal in reptiles and vitellogenin production by male fish, may result from estrogenic action of chemicals in the environment. Fewer data are available concerning the mammals. However, some endangered species such as Florida panthers that are exposed to estrogenic and/or other endocrine-disrupting contaminants show reproductive disorders comparable to those found in the human.
Sexual Differentiation and the Physiological Role of Estrogens
Sexual Differentiation
Sexual differentiation occurs during the first trimester of human pregnancy (125). An indifferent gonad develops into a testis under the influence of the SRY gene on the Y chromosome. In addition to SRY, there are several downstream effectors and autosomal genes (e.g., SOX9 and SF-1) that are required for normal differentiation of the testis (126,127). Sertoli cells in the newly differentiated testis produce Müllerian inhibiting substance (MIS), which induces regression of the Müllerian ducts that would otherwise develop into the oviducts, uterus, and upper part of the vagina. Sertoli cells also regulate development and early function of the Leydig cells that secrete testosterone to promote differentiation of the embryonic Wolffian ducts into the male accessory sex organs, epididymides, seminal vesicles, and vasa deferentia. Masculinization of the external genitalia and the rest of the body, except the brain, is also controlled by androgens and occurs after conversion of testosterone from the testis into 5
-dihydrotestosterone in the target tissue. Female reproductive organs develop in the absence of SRY and thereby in the absence of the testis (128). The female developmental pattern seems to be a genetic default pathway, and it is largely independent of hormonal regulation. Disturbances in sexual differentiation occur when factors in the male developmental cascade go wrong or when the genetic female is exposed to an elevated plasma-androgen concentration. In the first instance, a genetic male will develop a female phenotype and in the latter case a female will be virilized.
Disorders of Genital Development and Testicular Malignancy
The association between disorders of genital development and sexual differentiation and gonadal malignancy has been observed since the beginning of this century and is now well established (129-131). The most frequent abnormality leading to neoplasia is gonadal dysgenesis with the presence of Y chromosomal material; other disorders include true hermaphroditism and androgen-insensitivity syndrome. Although the general prevalence of disorders of sex differentiation is low, the high incidence of germ cell tumors makes the intersex gonad a good model for the study of factors involved in the pathogenesis of germ-cell neoplasia. Malignant growth frequently appears in the intersex gonad in early childhood, thus suggesting that the carcinogenic process begins in utero. The intersex syndrome comprises a variety of genetic disorders, as different from each other as, for example, XY/XO mosaicism and a mutation in the androgen receptor gene. The phenomenon of heterogeneous genetic defects leading to a common result, malignancy of germ cells, indicates that any disruption of early gonadal development may render the germ cells susceptible to neoplastic transformation by yet unknown mechanisms. There are some hypotheses concerning possible mechanisms of neoplastic transformation --e.g., arrested differentiation of immature germ cells (132)--or an imbalance in fetal hormonal environment (133). Androgen-insensitivity syndrome provides a clue that the lack of the appropriate inductive hormonal environment may arrest fetal gonadal differentiation and lead to neoplasia later in life. It is possible that high levels of testicular androgens have a protective function during gonadal development; for example, a relative excess of maternal testosterone during early pregnancy was shown in black women compared to a matched white group, providing a possible explanation for the lower incidence of testicular cancer in black men (134). There is some experimental evidence that androgens and estrogens may have opposite effects on certain pathways in the developing gonad; e.g., free estrogen may decrease expression of MIS (135,136), whereas androgens seem to have a stimulatory effect (137).
The Physiological Role of Estrogens in Sexual Differentiation
Estrogens act through a nuclear receptor that is a ligand-activated transcription factor. In addition, steroid hormones may effect the cell membrane. Estrogens are essential in the development of female secondary sexual characteristics and in the female reproductive cycle, fertility, and maintenance of pregnancy. In the developing male, the physiological role(s) of estrogens is unclear, though by analogy to the situation in adulthood, they probably play a role in regulating the differentiation and function of Leydig cells (138). The role of estrogen action in embryonic sexual differentiation is controversial. In rats and rabbits (139,140), estrogen synthesis is activated in male and female embryos at the time of blastocyst implantation in the uterus. Estrogen receptor mRNA can be detected in blastocysts and two-cell stage embryos (141). Immunohistochemical studies by Greco et al. (142) demonstrated estrogen receptor expression in both male and female mouse gonads on fetal day 13 and 15. The gonads lose their estrogen receptor expression at later ages. These studies suggested a role for estrogens in development of the gonads (143). A putative molecular target of estrogens could be the MIS gene that contains a DNA sequence similar to the estrogen response element in the upstream regulatory region (144). In contrast, the classical organ ablation studies by Jost (145) demonstrated that gonadectomy of the embryo always resulted in a female phenotype. However, maternal and placental estrogens might still have contributed to this developmental pattern.
Defects in the Estrogen Receptor Gene
Recent reports on estrogen receptor gene-deleted mice (146) and a male patient with a defective estrogen receptor (147) have begun to clarify the possible importance of endogenous estrogens in sexual development. Lubahn et al. (146) disrupted the estrogen receptor gene by targeted deletion that resulted in complete estrogen resistance. Both male and female mice survived to adulthood without apparent morphological anomalies. However, females were infertile with hypoplastic uteri and hyperemic ovaries that contained no corpora lutea. Fertility of the males was also decreased. Only 3 of 15 males that paired with normal females produced any offspring, and even those that were initially fertile lost their ability to sire subsequent litters. Testicular weights were low and sperm counts (in the testis and epididymis) were only 10% of control. Weights of seminal vesicles and coagulating gland were normal. These findings suggest that estrogens are necessary but not indispensable for fetal sexual development; i.e., development is overtly normal, but the sexual organs do not reach their normal size and function.
There is only one reported patient case of estrogen resistance--a 28-year-old white male (147). This man had incomplete epiphyseal closure and therefore continued linear growth into adulthood despite otherwise normal pubertal development. He was normally masculinized and had normal male genitalia with bilateral descended testes (20 and 25 ml) and a normal-sized prostate gland. His sexual functions were normal including morning erections and nocturnal emissions. However, his semen quality was subnormal: sperm concentration was 25 million/ml and viability 18% (normal values: >20 million; >50%, respectively). His serum testosterone concentration was normal, whereas estradiol, estrone, follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), and LH concentrations were elevated. The elevated gonadotropin concentrations suggest that estrogens play a role in the regulation of gonadotropin secretion in males, and thereby may have several indirect effects. The patient case and the receptor gene-deleted mice demonstrate that a normal male phenotype develops in the absence of estrogen receptor-mediated influences, but semen quality and probably fertility may be compromised as a result.
Overexpression of the Estrogen Receptor
In transgenic mice that overexpress the estrogen receptor, normal differentiation of sexual organs was observed (148). However, females in several transgenic lines had fertility problems and their gestational length was significantly prolonged, resulting in loss of litters due to difficulties in parturition. No major fertility problems were reported in the male transgenics. The only abnormalities described in the males (as well as in the females) were hernias of the abdominal wall musculature. This is of interest, since estrogen administration has been reported to induce inguinal hernias in male mice (149), and dogs (150,151), and there is some indication that inguinal hernias are a risk factor for testicular cancer (152). It is not known yet whether transgenic male mice that overexpress the estrogen receptor will develop testicular tumors later in life.
Nonmammalian Vertebrates
Amphibians and birds differ from mammals in their sexual differentiation (153). That is, the female phenotype in birds develops under estrogen control, whereas the male phenotype appears in the absence of estrogen (154). Exogenous estrogen administration causes sex reversal in male birds and frogs. Some reptiles (crocodilians and some turtles) have temperature-dependent sex determination; for example, in turtles, female hatchlings are produced by incubation of the eggs at a higher temperature than males, but an excess of estrogen causes feminine differentiation also at low temperatures typical of males (155,156). Estrogen-induced sex reversal can be used as a biomarker of the estrogenicity of an environmental pollutant, as demonstrated recently for PCBs (99). Estrogen receptors are expressed both in female and male chick embryos in the Müllerian ducts (154). Interestingly, the left Müllerian duct that develops into an oviduct in females (regresses in male) has higher estrogen binding capacity than the right, which regresses in both sexes (157). Treatment of chick embryos with diethylstilbestrol (DES) on day 5 prevented regression of the Müllerian ducts in both sexes (158). Similar findings in the mouse are reviewed in the section "Effects of Synthetic Estrogens on the Testis in Animal Models."
Estrogens and Sperm Production Capacity
Sperm production is dependent on permissive actions of FSH and testosterone (and therefore LH). Sperm production capacity depends on the number of Sertoli cells in the seminiferous tubules (which is directly related to the length of the tubules) (159), since each Sertoli cell supports a finite number of germ cells (160). Sertoli cells proliferate quickly in rats from embryonic day 19 to day 15 after birth, then slow down and cease multiplication approximately on postnatal day 20 (161,162). Multiplication is largely dependent on FSH stimulation (162). In humans, regulation of Sertoli-cell proliferation may be very similar. Men with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism do not develop normal-sized testes after gonadotropin treatment, which may be a consequence of inadequate Sertoli cell multiplication in early childhood. This hypothesis is supported by findings in the monkey (163): Sertoli cells proliferate in the neonatal and infantile period but not during or after puberty. Estrogens suppress gonadotropin production in animals at all ages preceding puberty (164). It is hypothesized that this is the case also in humans. Decreased gonadotropin stimulation during the critical developmental phase may result in inadequate Sertoli cell proliferation and small testes (165). Specific FSH gene deletion experiments also demonstrated that FSH regulates the size of the testis (TR Kumaar, personal communication). At present it is not known whether the number of Sertoli cells in human testes has decreased and whether this might be a reason for decreased sperm counts.
Summary
Normal masculine differentiation occurs under the influence of the SRY gene and several other autosomal genes, and androgens are required for this process. Disorders of gonadal development are frequently associated with testicular germ cell neoplasia. Estrogens act through a specific nuclear receptor. Normal masculine differentiation occurs even in the absence of a functioning estrogen receptor, but the patient with the receptor defect had poor semen quality. Estrogen receptor-deficient male mice were subfertile and few were able to sire one litter. Estrogens are involved in the feedback regulation of gonadotropin secretion, and the suppression of FSH secretion during the period of Sertoli cell proliferation (perinatal period) may result in small testes and a low sperm production capacity in adult life.
Occurrence of Abnormalities in the Reproductive System of the Sons of Women Exposed to Diethylstilbestrol during Pregnancy
Exposure
Diethylstilbestrol (DES) was prescribed to more than five million pregnant women from the late 1940s to the early 1970s to prevent abortions and pregnancy complications (166). Dieckmann and co-workers performed a double-blind placebo-controlled study on the therapeutic value of DES during pregnancy in the early 1950s (167). DES was given to 840 pregnant women and placebo to 806 controls. Compliance was verified by a dye indicator in the urine during the whole study. The women entered the study between weeks 7 and 20 of pregnancy (the majority during weeks 10-12) and received increasing doses of DES until pregnancy week 35 (5-150 mg/day). This study clearly indicated that the medication was not efficacious in the indications for which it was used (167). Instead, in the reanalysis of the material of Dieckmann et al. (167), DES was associated with significant increases in abortions, neonatal deaths, and premature births (168). When Herbst and co-workers (169,170) reported the high incidence of a very rare cancer, clear cell adenocarcinoma of the vagina, in pubertal girls exposed to DES in utero, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) banned the use of DES during pregnancy. Medical authorities in Europe that had allowed DES use for pregnant women soon followed FDA regulations. In Europe, approximately 200,000 French, more than 150,000 Dutch, 63,000 Czechoslovakian, and 7000 British women were exposed to DES, whereas in the United States 4.8 million women were prescribed DES during pregnancy. In addition, DES was used as an anabolic agent in livestock, and the general population that used dairy products and meat may have been exposed to the hormone via this route to an unknown, and probably variable, extent. Some of the DES-exposed daughters and sons have been followed since the 1970s and a significant number of abnormalities in the structure and function of reproductive organs have been described (171).
Structural Anomalies
Structural anomalies of the reproductive organs that are significantly more frequent in DES-exposed male subjects than in controls include meatal stenosis (12.9 vs 1.8%); hypospadias (4.4 vs 0%); epididymal cysts (20.8 vs 4.9%); testicular abnormalities, including hypoplastic testis, cryptorchidism, and capsular induration (11.4 vs 2.9%); and microphallus (4 cases vs 0 cases) (172-174). The data of Bibbo and Gill and their co-workers (173,174) are based on the follow-up studies of the offspring of mothers who took part in the double-blind study of the effects of DES on pregnancy in 1953 (167), and therefore the studies can be considered prospective. There were 308 men exposed to DES and 307 men exposed to placebo included in the study; 31.5% of men exposed to DES had an abnormality of their reproductive tract, whereas only 7.8% of controls had an anomaly (174). In the recent follow-up study of these males, it was found that the men who were exposed to DES before week 11 of gestation had twice as high a frequency of genital anomalies than did those who were exposed only later (175). This finding indicates the importance of the timing of the exposure (time of organogenesis). In a small study comprising 17 DES-exposed men, 12 nonexposed volunteers, and 11 fertile control men, genital anomalies (varicocele, epididymal cysts, absent testes) were reported in 13 of the DES-exposed subjects, 4 of the volunteers and 4 of the fertile normal controls (176). Whitehead and Leiter (177) reported genital abnormalities in 29 of 48 men exposed to DES. Hypertrophy and squamous metaplasia of the prostatic utricle was found more frequently in aborted male fetuses that had been exposed to DES than in nonexposed controls (178), suggesting that DES-exposed males may have an increased risk of prostatic hyperplasia and/or cancer when aging. The data connecting DES exposure to several structural abnormalities of the male reproductive tract are convincing and leave little space for speculation on confounding factors. However, no association was found between first-trimester exposure to sex hormones, other than DES, and external genital abnormalities in a recent metaanalysis of 14 studies (179). In a large cryptorchidism study, no association between the disorder and exposure to estrogens during the pregnancy could be found (180).
Semen Quality
Gill et al. (181) studied semen samples from 88 men exposed to DES and 85 men exposed to placebo, who were offspring of the mothers from the 1953 study performed by Dieckmann and co-workers (167). Sperm concentration of men exposed to DES was significantly lower than in the controls (83 million/ml vs 123 million/ml, p<0.02). There was no difference in semen volume, whereas the total sperm count, sperm motility grade, the total number of motile sperm, the percentage of sperm with normal morphology, and the quality score were all statistically lower in men exposed to DES. Azoospermia was found only in men exposed to DES, and 20.5% compared to 3.5% of men who received placebo had a sperm concentration in semen of less than 20 million/ml. The groups did not differ in their testosterone, FSH, or LH levels (173). In a later study on the same men (20 controls declined to participate), sperm concentrations still differed significantly, whereas other semen characteristics were similar between the groups (182). Similar results were obtained in another study (176) in which the mean sperm concentration of men exposed to DES was 66.4 million/ml compared to 101.7 million/ml in normal volunteers (p<0.05). In this study, the zona-free hamster egg penetration assay was also performed: sperm from 14 of 17 men exposed to DES failed to penetrate more than 14% of the eggs (which is the reference value for the normal fertility range), suggesting infertility, whereas only 2 of 12 unexposed volunteers and none of 11 fertile normal controls had an abnormal test result. In the study performed by Whitehead and Leiter (177), only 33% of the men exposed to DES had normal semen quality. However, Andonian and Kessler (183) found no difference in semen quality between 24 men exposed to DES and 24 age-matched control men. Again, the large 1953 study population that has been followed prospectively appears the most valid for evaluation of semen quality. On the basis of that finding, DES exposure resulted in a significant decrease in semen quality.
Semen quality and fertility are not in direct correlation. In the latest follow-up study of the Dieckmann cohort, no difference in the fertility between men exposed to DES and their controls were found (175). This is compatible with the earlier findings (181) that the majority of the men exposed to DES had sperm concentrations well above the limit at which fertility is supposed to be disturbed (20 million/ml), although the mean sperm concentrations of exposed men were lower than those of controls.
Testicular Cancer
There is no conclusive evidence to indicate an increased risk of testicular cancer in men exposed to DES (184), although the incidence of cryptorchidism is a well-known risk factor for testicular cancer and has been observed more frequently in this group (171). Two patient cases with seminoma in men exposed to DES have been reported (185), but epidemiological studies have failed to show a statistically significant relationship between DES exposure and testicular cancer. There have been a few case-control studies that evaluated prenatal hormonal risk factors for testicular cancer (186-191). In the first study (186), 131 testicular cancer patients, under age 40, and their matched controls were analyzed. In 6 cases of cancer the mothers had been treated with hormones during pregnancy, whereas only one mother of the control cases had received any hormones. The difference was not statistically significant, but if another factor, nausea, was combined with hormone treatment, they formed a significant risk factor (relative risk 4.33).
In the case-control study of Depue et al. (187), 108 testicular cancer patients, under age 30, were studied. Mothers of 9 cancer patients had been treated with hormones (2 with DES, 1 with estrogen, 1 with progestin, and 5 had pregnancy tests consisting of a single injection of an estrogen-progestin preparation), whereas 2 controls had either estrogen treatment or a pregnancy test. The relative risk (8.00) was significantly increased in the men exposed to hormones (p=0.02). However, the exposures were very heterogeneous, and single pregnancy tests can hardly be compared to long-term DES treatment.
In a similar study comprising 202 cancer cases and 206 controls, Brown et al. (189) found no excess risk associated with the use of hormones during pregnancy: mothers of 4 cancer patients and 5 control mothers had received hormone treatment. Two mothers in each group had been treated with DES, 1 control with estrogen, 1 case with progesterone, 1 in each group had a hormone pregnancy test, and 1 control had an unidentified hormone treatment. However, it should be noted that 19 mothers in this study were medicated for bleeding problems, but only 2 (both case mothers) mentioned a specific hormone used; 13 of the treated were case mothers and 6 were control mothers.
In a case-control study of 273 testicular cancer patients from northern California (190), no association was found with the mother's hormone exposure or DES exposure. Mothers of 9 cases and 10 controls had been treated with hormones (odds ratio 0.9). Four of the case mothers and 2 control mothers were exposed to DES.
The case-control study of Schottenfeld et al. (188) was based on questionnaires received from 190 testicular cancer patients (The Sloan Kettering Cancer Hospital, New York), 166 hospital controls, and 143 neighborhood controls. There was no statistically significant association between hormone treatment and cancer: 5.8% (n=11) of cases had been exposed to DES or other hormones, whereas 2.1% (n=3) of the neighborhood controls and 2.5% (n=4) of the hospital controls had received exogenous hormones. Similarly, a case-control study of 79 testicular cancer patients from the Connecticut Tumor Registry failed to show any increased cancer risk in men exposed to DES (191).
The studies above have been described in detail because they illustrate two major problems. First, DES treatment may have been initiated at various times during pregnancy; therefore, the presumed critical period during which adverse effects of estrogens might occur may have been missed in some of these studies. Second, the investigated populations of testicular cancer patients have been too small to determine if a significant difference truly exists between DES-exposed and nonexposed men. When we combined the data presented above in a metaanalysis, a marginally significant increase in testicular cancer incidence for the individuals exposed to hormones (including all hormones) was found; Mantel-Haenszel estimates of the common odds ratio was 2.1 with 95% confidence intervals of 1.3 to 3.3. Exposure to DES was a significant risk factor for testicular cancer on the basis of our metaanalysis: odds ratio was 2.6 with 95% confidence limits of 1.1 to 6.1. It would be most important to obtain additional information on the incidence of testicular cancer in men born to mothers who participated in the double-blind, placebo-controlled DES trial in the 1950s (167).
Summary
Exposure to DES during pregnancy results in an increased risk for several male reproductive disorders, such as cryptorchidism, urethral abnormalities, epididymal cysts, and testicular hypoplasia. In addition, the semen quality of DES sons is worse than that of controls. Incidence of testicular cancer is approximately doubled among DES sons compared to the general population, but whether this represents a true increase of the cancer risk is equivocal.
Effects of Synthetic Estrogens on the Testis in Animal Models
Synthetic estrogens, such as DES, ethinyl estradiol, and estradiol benzoate have been thoroughly studied in several animal models because of their pharmaceutical applications. There are comprehensive reviews covering this topic (164,192,193).
Mechanism of Action
The effects of estrogens depend on the dose, time, and probably the duration of exposure. Estrogens also act at several levels in the reproductive system, i.e., they influence specific neuronal areas in the brain, they modulate gonadotropin secretion from the pituitary gland, and they directly affect the reproductive organs. Estrogens probably exert most or all of their effects through a specific receptor; such receptors are present in the brain, pituitary, gonads, and accessory sex organs at one or another time during fetal, prepubertal, or adult life (143). However, the precise localization and temporal expression of estrogen receptors during differentiation and development of the testis and male reproductive tract are poorly described and further, more definitive, studies are needed. The effects of DES are not unique to this compound but are probably shared by all estrogens (164). Many of the synthetic estrogens are more effective in lower doses than endogenous estradiol because they are not bound by sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG), which normally binds approximately 95% of circulating estradiol, rendering it biologically inactive. Estrogens are metabolized rapidly in the testes, e.g., by specific sulfotransferases, after which they cannot bind to their receptor (194). If the active center of the enzyme is occupied by a xenobiotic, metabolism of endogenous estrogens may be disturbed and high levels of active hormone may be available. This is particularly important during fetal development when the levels of ambient estrogens are high.
Adverse Effects of Neonatal Estrogen Treatment
Long-lasting suppression of spermatogenesis and atrophy of reproductive organs in neonatally estrogen-treated rats and mice have been described by many workers since the 1950s (164). A single injection of estradiol benzoate (250 µg on day 5) resulted in a marked delay of the onset of puberty in rats (195). When mice were treated with repeated doses of estradiol on days 1 to 5 after birth, the testes were irreversibly damaged, and subsequent treatment with testosterone and gonadotropins failed to maintain spermatogenesis in the majority of these estrogenized mice (196). These two studies are cited because they indicate that estrogens given neonatally act directly on both the testes and the pituitary gland. It is noteworthy that the neonatal period in rodents corresponds in many ways to the second and third trimesters of pregnancy in the human.
Adverse Effects of Prenatal Estrogen Treatment
Prenatal (day 11 and 12 postcoitum) exposure of mice from the Sv-Sl CP strain (a strain in which the males are susceptible to testicular teratomas) to ethinyl estradiol resulted in an increased incidence of cryptorchidism (p=0.0001), and 19 of 224 exposed male animals developed testicular teratoma compared to 4 out of 107 controls (the odds ratio of 2.4 was not significantly different) (197).
McLachlan and co-workers have performed a large series of studies on the effects of prenatal exposure of mice to DES (192,193). In most of the studies, pregnant mice were treated with 0.01, 1, 10, or 100 µg/kg/day DES or corn oil on days 9 to 16 of pregnancy (time of sexual differentiation). The high doses are closely equivalent to those used for pregnant women (173). Male offspring from these pregnancies suffered from the same structural and functional anomalies reported in men exposed to DES, i.e., epididymal cysts, cellular atypia in the prostate, cryptorchidism, testicular hypoplasia, poor semen quality, and subfertility (192). In addition, Sertoli-cell hyperplasia, interstitial testicular tumors, squamous metaplasia of the seminal vesicles, and rete testis adenocarcinoma were found frequently in the male offspring of mice exposed to DES during pregnancy (198). The analogy between the findings in the human and the mouse illustrates how informative and relevant the results from animal studies are.
Estrogen Effects on the Müllerian Ducts
Müllerian inhibiting substance secreted by Sertoli cells is responsible for regression of the Müllerian ducts. Analysis of male mouse embryos exposed to DES revealed delayed and incomplete regression of the Müllerian ducts (192). In vitro organ culture experiments verified the inhibitory action of DES on Müllerian duct regression (136). Estrogen receptors were found both in the Müllerian ducts and Sertoli cells at the time of regression (143). Estrogens could either affect the Müllerian ducts directly or influence the expression of the MIS gene in the Sertoli cells. Some of the structural abnormalities observed after birth may arise as a result of incomplete regression of the Müllerian ducts (198).
Estrogen Effects on the Developing Testis
Reports on various experimental animals (e.g., sheep, rats, mice) describe how exposure to exogenous estrogens during the neonatal period causes drastic reductions in the secretion of FSH from the pituitary gland and the presumption is that similar effects would occur before birth (199). As FSH plays a vital role in controlling multiplication of Sertoli cells at this time (138) the prediction would be that estrogen-induced suppression of FSH levels would lead to a slower rate of Sertoli cell multiplication. As the number of Sertoli cells formed in fetal/neonatal life is an important factor influencing the maximum level of sperm production in adult life, the consequences of such a change in terms of sperm counts is obvious; moreover, such an effect is irreversible once Sertoli cell multiplication stops in early postnatal life. There is abundant evidence from man (hypogonadotropic hypogonadism) and from animal species that suppression of FSH levels in early postnatal life results in just such changes [reviewed by Sharpe (138)]. Recent evidence from the fetal sheep (165) also shows that suppression of FSH secretion in the fetal male during the second half of gestation results at birth in testes that contain 40% fewer Sertoli cells than occurs in control animals.
It is therefore hypothesized that prolonged exposure of the developing male, during both fetal and postnatal life, to exogenous estrogens (perhaps even at low levels) could reduce Sertoli cell number and thus reduce sperm output (and sperm counts) in adult life. Experiments involving exposure of rats to various xenoestrogens during the period of Sertoli cell multiplication have shown that in adult life such exposure results in small (8-12%) but highly significant reductions in testis size and a corresponding decrease in daily sperm production (200). These effects have been achieved after exposure to relatively low levels of the chemicals (alkylphenols, phthalates; 1 mg/liter in drinking water of pregnant rats) under test. For example, butylbenzyl phthalate has been found to occur in butter and margarine at concentrations as high as 47.8 mg/kg (201). Such findings suggest that there is the theoretical possibility that human exposure to such chemicals might have contributed to the decline in sperm counts in men described earlier.
Summary
Diethylstilbestrol treatment of experimental animals in utero results in increased incidence of cryptorchidism; urethral abnormalities; testicular hypoplasia; poor semen quality; and infertility, abnormalities in accessory sex organs, rete testis adenocarcinoma, interstitial cell hyperplasia, and tumors. Thus, the outcome of DES exposure of experimental animals is highly analogous to the findings in humans. Recent data in the rat suggest that perinatal exposure to xenoestrogens, such as butylbenzyl phthalate, results in decreased size of the testes and daily sperm production in adult life.
Environmental Chemicals with Known Estrogenic Effects
Estrogenic effects are not restricted to a small group of therapeutic agents but appear in several groups of compounds that are used daily in industry, agriculture, or in the home (79,80,202-204). The major groups of environmental chemicals, such as organochlorine pesticides, PCBs, dioxins, alkylphenol polyethoxylates, phytoestrogens, and other xenoestrogens, currently known to have estrogenic effects in vertebrates or in assays in vitro are discussed here. A major problem is the determination of those chemicals that are estrogenic (or otherwise endocrine-disrupting, i.e., disturbing normal endocrine homeostasis). At present, tens of thousands of man-made chemicals are being used, yet the effects on the endocrine system have been studied for only a few of these. The estrogenic activity of the majority of chemicals (e.g., alkylphenols, phthalate esters, bisphenol-A) has been detected by accident, not by intent, although recently some screening of chemicals used in large volumes has been attempted (204). Hence, it is highly possible that other estrogenic chemicals remain unidentified. However, it should be remembered that many of the chemicals to which man is exposed have been tested (often in two- or three-generation studies) before being approved for use; and hence, if any of these chemicals were a strong estrogen, this would probably have been discovered. This is especially the case for chemicals that are currently approved for use in food production, such as food additives and pesticides, and for new chemicals that have been produced in large amounts from the early 1980s in the European Union (EU). The current legislation demands extensive documentation for safety by regulatory agencies before a chemical can be used in foods or commercial products. However, many chemicals were introduced before these strict regulations were enforced. Thus, the present situation is that man and wildlife are exposed to a very wide range of chemicals. For the majority of these we do not know whether they are estrogenic, whether their effects are additive, or even what the true exposure to these chemicals is.
A xenoestrogen can induce its estrogenic effect in multiple ways: it may act directly through estrogen receptors, or it may disturb estrogen metabolism, thus increasing the levels of the endogenously produced ligand. Different estrogenic and antiestrogenic ligands form functionally different complexes with the estrogen receptor, and their transcriptional effects depend on the cell type and promoter (205). Thus, the same compound may potentially have an estrogenic effect in one system or at one concentration, and an antiestrogenic effect in another system or at another concentration. Furthermore, effects of many compounds influencing other hormone systems (e.g., antiandrogens) may mimic those of estrogens.
A number of chemicals, mainly pesticides and many of which are currently being used, have been implicated as environmental hormones possessing endocrine-disrupting properties (80). In the public debate on male reproductive disorders, this has misled many to suppose that all of these chemicals are estrogenic. In fact, many of these compounds have not been adequately tested for estrogenic activity. However, for many others, a large toxicological database exists, including data on reproductive toxicity, effects on steroid-metabolizing enzymes, and effects on hormone-producing tissues. A short summary of the most relevant toxicologic effects known for a number of xenoestrogens and other environmental chemicals that have been implicated as environmental hormones is given in "Appendix A." It also outlines the safety assessment procedures and principles applied world-wide by regulatory agencies.
Below is a short examination of each of the groups of chemicals that are known to be estrogenic.
Organochlorine Pesticides
Organochlorine pesticides include dichlorodiphenylethanes (DDT, DDD, DDE, dicofol, perthane, methoxychlor), cyclodienes (chlordane, oxychlordane, trans-nonachlor, heptachlor, heptachlorepoxide, aldrin, and dieldrin), hexachlorobenzene, and hexachlorocyclohexanes (206). Many of these, most notably DDT, were used in large quantities until the 1960s when the use of DDT was banned or restricted in Western countries. Hexachlorobenzene, however, was used in the United States until 1985. DDT products are still used widely in many developing countries. Despite restrictions on their use, these compounds are still circulating in the environment because many of them bioaccumulate and become concentrated in body lipids (biomagnify). The breakdown and elimination of these compounds is very slow; therefore, their effects can be persistent, lasting for generations (DDT has a half-life of >60 years in the environment). Long-term exposure to small amounts of organochlorine contaminants leads to the accumulation of considerable burdens in animal and human tissues (207,208). It is therefore not the amount of DDT to which a mother is exposed during pregnancy that is critical but rather her lifetime exposure that will determine the level of exposure of the fetus and the breast-fed infant.
Commercial DDT contains several isomers of which p,p´-DDT is the most prevalent (75-80%), whereas the proportion of the most estrogenic isomer o,p´-DDT is 10 to 25% (89,209). The o,p´-isomers are less stable than the p,p´ configurations and are therefore found only in low concentrations in nature (210). However, p,p´-DDT was also reported to have estrogenic actions both on the rat uterus (211) and in the MCF-7 breast cancer cell line (212). The estrogenic activity of DDT isomers compared to that of estradiol is very weak (103-106 times less potent). However, the long half-life and bioaccumulative properties of DDT indicate that levels of human exposure may be sufficient to induce estrogenic effects in certain circumstances. This is particularly true for the period from the 1940s to 1960s when DDT was used widely including in direct application to humans.
Antiandrogenic (demasculinizing) and estrogenic (feminizing) effects often manifest themselves in the same way, although through distinct receptors (213). Therefore the recent discovery that p,p´-DDE, the main metabolite of DDT in the body, is a potent antiandrogen (214) may explain some of the estrogenic effects observed in the environment; many of these effects may occur due to an antiandrogen activity of a xenobiotic.
Fry and Toone (115) induced feminization in male California gulls (Larus californicus) by injecting eggs with DDT in amounts that were comparable to those found in seabird eggs in southern California in the late 1960s. A skewed sex ratio in favor of females in large gull populations suggested the possibility of a causal relationship with the estrogenic action of DDT (86). The effects of DDT metabolites and dicofol in reptiles have been discussed in the section "Changes in Male Reproduction in Wildlife. Estrogenic Effects on Developing Animals." In mammals, the effects of DDT compounds on male reproductive function are less apparent (215).
Methoxychlor is estrogenic in the E-SCREEN assay (204). It was also found to be estrogenic in vivo in rats (216). Methoxychlor or DDT exposure of neonatal rats did not affect male reproductive organ weights in adulthood (217), and neither induced epididymal cysts (218), which were found frequently in mice exposed to DES (192). However, exposure throughout gestation and lactation in rodents resulted in slightly smaller testes and epididymides and in lower sperm counts in male offspring than in controls (219,220). It was suggested that the inability of the neonatal rodent to metabolize methoxychlor to its active estrogenic form might explain the discrepancy between these studies (220).
Chlorinated cyclodienes induce liver enzymes that hydroxylate testosterone (221). Chlordane disturbed spermatogenesis and caused dose-related damage to the testes of mice fed for 30 days with 0.08 mg or 0.25 mg of the active ingredient (222). Mating studies of dieldrin-exposed rats suggest male-dependent disturbances in fertility (223). In the E-SCREEN assay, chlordane and heptachlor were not estrogenic, but the heptachlor derivative 1-hydroxy chlordane was (212). In addition, dieldrin was shown to be estrogenic (81).
Hexachlorobenzene was also reported to induce liver enzymes hydroxylating androgens (221). Long-term studies have demonstrated liver and kidney anomalies in exposed animals but indicate no effect on fertility (224).
Hexachlorocyclohexanes (HCHs) comprise several isomeric forms; these compounds are also called benzene hexachloride (BHC). 
-HCH has the common name lindane and is the most acutely toxic of the isomers (215). The most persistent and bioaccumulating isomer is ß-HCH, which accounts for 90% of the total HCH found in human milk (225). Lindane was reported to have both estrogenic and antiestrogenic effects in female rats (226). In male weanling rats fed with ß-HCH (0, 2, 10, 50, or 250 mg/kg) for 13 weeks, liver enzyme induction occurred at doses >2 mg/kg; testis weights decreased at doses >50 mg/kg; and testicular atrophy resulted from a dose of 250 mg/kg (227).
In hamsters, a single injection of the weakly estrogenic chlordecone (Kepone) in neonatal males reduced testicular and epididymal weight (228). Estrogenicity of chlordecone was also demonstrated in rats (229) and birds (230).
Polychlorinated Biphenyls
Polychlorinated biphenyls are industrial chemicals used since 1929 as heat transfer and hydraulic fluids, adhesives, flame retardants, dielectric fluids for capacitors and transformers, and waxes (231). PCBs consist of 209 congeners, which are found in different mixtures in commercial products. Before the production of PCBs was banned in the United States in 1977, hundreds of millions of kilograms were produced, and a large proportion of the synthesized product is still in the environment because of bioaccumulation and slow biotransformation.
The biological effects caused by the various congeners differ, not only in potency but also qualitatively. Several non-ortho- and mono-ortho-substituted PCB congeners induce effects similar to those caused by chlorinated dioxins and dibenzofurans; i.e., the toxicity is probably mediated through interaction with the aryl hydrocarbon (Ah) receptor. Other PCB congeners presumably act by different mechanisms. In addition, there are PCB congeners that are intermediate in this respect; i.e., they elicit a mixed spectrum of effects. Our knowledge of possible interactions between the various groups of PCBs is still very limited (232).
Both estrogenic and antiestrogenic effects have been reported for different PCB congeners (233). The estrogenic potency appears to depend on the percentage of chlorine: less-chlorinated PCBs (Aroclors 1221, 1232, 1242, and 1248) have estrogenic activity whereas more chlorinated congeners do not (209). The stability of the compounds increases with higher chlorination. Less-chlorinated compounds were shown to transfer more readily across the placenta than were the highly chlorinated PCBs (234). PCBs are hydroxylated in animals, and these hydroxybiphenyls are quite active as estrogenic compounds [i.e., more than 1/100 of estradiol activity (235)]. Antiestrogenic effects have been found in MCF-7 breast cancer cells with 3,3´,4,4´-tetrachloro-biphenyl (a dioxinlike PCB), a form known to bind to the Ah receptor, mediating the effect (233). Reproductive failure of seals in the Wadden Sea has been attributed to PCBs (236), and has been supported by laboratory studies (121). However, this relationship may not necessarily have been a consequence of the estrogenicity of the PCBs.
Dioxins and Furans. Polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDDs) and polychlorinated dibenzofurans (PCDFs) consist of 75 and 135 different congeners, respectively (237). The most toxic congener is 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD), commonly referred to as dioxin. These compounds are formed as unwanted by-products in the manufacture of chlorinated hydrocarbons. Other sources include incineration processes, paper and pulp bleaching, and emissions from steel foundries and from motor vehicles (238).
Most of the animal studies on dioxins have been performed with TCDD [reviewed by Peterson et al. (239)]. Dioxins act through an Ah receptor that is also involved in mediating the antiestrogenic effects of TCDD (240,241). However, the role of the Ah receptor has not been established for several of the toxic effects that are found in males exposed to TCDD (242). There is considerable literature documenting the toxic effects of dioxins on the male reproductive system (239,242). Prenatal and lactational exposure of male rats to TCDD profoundly disturbed the developing male reproductive organs: anogenital distance was shortened, testicular descent was delayed, and the weights of all sex organs were reduced (243). Furthermore, spermatogenesis was inhibited, sexual behavior was feminized and demasculinized, and the regulation of LH secretion was feminized (244-246). Perinatal suppression of plasma testosterone concentrations appeared to be involved in the changes described. The effects were elicited by a single maternal oral dose of TCDD on day 15 of pregnancy [ED50 approximately 0.16 µg/kg; at this dose, TCDD had no discernible effect on the mother (242)]. Most of the effects were found at the lowest dose level tested (0.064 µg/kg), whereas in other studies, reproductive toxicity had been observed with doses of <0.001 µg/kg/day (247,248). The mechanism of action of dioxins and furans may not be primarily estrogenic or antiestrogenic (e.g., antiestrogenic effects of TCDD cannot be reversed by high estrogen concentrations), but it is certainly a hormonelike effect. This necessitates the close surveillance of humans exposed to TCDD.
Alkylphenol Polyethoxylates
Alkylphenols and related compounds are present in surface waters and aquatic sediments (249-251). They are products of the microbial breakdown of alkylphenol polyethoxylates (APEs) that are widely used in industrial surfactants (250,251). These effective, nonionic surfactants are used in detergents, paints, herbicides, pesticides, and cosmetics, to name a few major groups of products. Over 300 million kilograms of APEs are produced annually. After sewage treatment, approximately 60% of the APEs are released into the aquatic environment as short-chain APEs (e.g., nonylphenoldiethoxylate [NP2EO]), alkylphenol carboxylic acids (e.g., nonylphenoxycarboxylic acid [NP1EC]), and alkylphenols (e.g., nonylphenol [NP]; and octylphenol [OP]) (252-254). Alkylphenols are relatively persistent and bioaccumulate in the lipids of living organisms (255,256).
NP and OP were shown to be estrogenic both in vivo and in vitro in mammalian systems (202,257). The effects were estrogen receptor mediated. OP was more potent than NP, reaching approximately 1/1000 of the potency of estradiol. In the trout hepatocyte assay, many other APEs were also shown to be weakly estrogenic (111).
Phytoestrogens
Phytoestrogens are natural compounds present in plants and are ingested daily in milligram quantities. The active substances are isoflavones (genistein and daidzen) and coumestans (coumesterol) (258). Fungal metabolites, such as zearalenone, found in foodstuff (e.g., grain) also belong to the phytoestrogens. Reproductive disorders in sheep are well documented after the eating of red clover containing high amounts of genistein (259). Some of the food products rich in phytoestrogens include rye, wheat, cabbage, sprouts, spinach, and soybean. Soybean is by far the richest source of plant estrogens and is used ubiquitously in the food industry as a protein source, including infant milk formula substitutes. Phytoestrogens may not bioaccumulate or biomagnify but they are readily metabolized and excreted (260).
Phytoestrogens have been shown to have estrogenic effects both in vitro and in vivo (212,258,261). Feeding of rams with clover that is rich in isoflavone resulted in decreased sperm counts (262,263). The effects are receptor mediated and depending on the dose are either estrogenic or antiestrogenic in an adult animal (264,265). Because of these potential antiestrogenic effects, high doses of isoflavones in the diet have been proposed as being beneficial for reducing the risk of hormone-dependent cancers (266). However, little consideration has been given to neonatal and childhood life when exposure to phytoestrogens would be presumed to have nonbeneficial effects.
Other Xenoestrogens
Bisphenol-A, a plastic monomer that was released from polycarbonate flasks during autoclaving, was shown to have an estrogenic effect on MCF-7 breast cancer cells (267). Notably, bisphenol-A is used extensively as a plasticizer, e.g., it is used in the lacquer coating of food cans that are then heated for sterilization purposes (268). Other common chemicals used in the plastic industry include the phthalate esters, butylbenzyl phthalate and di-n-butylphthalate, which were shown to act as weak estrogens on breast cancer cells (203). In the E-SCREEN assay, di-n-butylphthalate was not estrogenic (204). Neither of the phthalate esters had antagonist effects, suggesting that their action may be cumulative (203). Phthalates are the most abundant man-made environmental pollutants; and human intake per day by various routes, especially through the diet, is measured in tens of milligrams (201). A food antioxidant, butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), was also estrogenic in breast cancer cell assays (203). However, the estrogenic potency of BHA and phthalate esters was lower than that of octylphenol or o,p´-DDT.
Summary
Numerous environmental chemicals, such as many organochlorine pesticides, PCBs, alkylphenol polyethoxylates, phthalates, and phytoestrogens are known to have estrogenic effects in vertebrates or in assays in vitro. However, only a few of the tens of thousands of man-made chemicals have been tested for estrogenic or other endocrine activity, and therefore, it is highly possible that other estrogenic chemicals remain unidentified. A major problem at present is how to fill this gap in our knowledge rapidly and cost effectively.
Exposure of Humans to Environmental Chemicals with Estrogenic Activity and Their Effects on Male Reproductive Health
The major routes of exposure to man-made chemicals are thought to be
- Dietary: pesticides, (including chemicals used in the formulation of commercial products), food additives (including synthetic flavoring substances), contaminants (such as PCBs, dioxins, metals, industrial chemicals, especially those that are biomagnified in food chains), packaging and wrapping materials (e.g., plastics, food wraps)
- Environmental: from the pollution of air and water
- Domestic: from contact with household products, cosmetics, clothing, and probably many others
- Occupational: inhalation, dermal contact and ingestion of active compounds, depending on the occupation.
Occupational exposure has not been considered in any detail in this report, which is aimed at describing the situation for the general population. However, valuable information on possible association between exposure to chemicals and effects on humans may originate from studies in occupational settings where high exposures have taken place. Because of better documentation and higher exposure, such studies are more likely to reveal adverse effects of chemicals on humans than are the studies on the general population (269).
The diet is usually regarded as the most important source of foreign chemicals. Very preliminary estimates of some exposures in Denmark are included in "Appendix A." It should not be overlooked that the exposure via routes other than food, such as air, drinking water, and particularly the skin (e.g., detergents) may be highly significant. Current knowledge on actual exposures is rather limited, in particular with regard to the domestic exposure to chemical products. A close examination of all possible exposures to chemicals suspected to be environmental hormones has not been possible within the constraints of this report. Humans may be exposed to xenoestrogens in multiple ways. Direct administration of synthetic hormones, such as DES or ethinyl estradiol is obvious, but the same hormones may be found in meat and dairy products in some countries (270). Cow's milk has a high concentration of endogenous estrogens during late gestation, and this milk is also collected for human consumption. The ratio of estrogens in this milk to that in plasma is generally greater than one (271), and therefore much higher than in human breast milk. Occupational exposure in the pharmaceutical industry is a possibility for a small minority. Estrogens occur in measurable amounts in sewage effluent used for irrigation (272). Phytoestrogens are ingested in large amounts, and weakly estrogenic alkylphenolic compounds are applied to the skin and ingested daily. Important issues to consider are the quantity of estrogenic compounds present, their potency, their capability to bioaccumulate and biomagnify, and their additive, synergistic, or antagonistic effects. Concentrations of organochlorine contaminants in human reproductive tissue, adipose tissue, and blood from the general population (Table A1) and in human breast milk (Table A2) worldwide are included in "Appendix 1"[adapted from Thomas and Colburn (206)].
Organochlorine Pesticides and Polychlorinated Biphenyls
The daily intake of DDT is now small in Europe and North America, and it may not have a significant influence alone. Chlordecone (Kepone), which is estrogenic, caused an occupational risk to workers exposed to high levels of the compound: exposed men had oligozoospermia, decreased sperm motility and abnormal sperm morphology (273).
Exposure to several organochlorine pesticides and PCBs at the same time may lead to untoward effects, as exemplified by the suggested association between slight disturbances of development in children exposed in utero and contaminants present in Lake Michigan fish (274-278). The risk was related to lifetime intake of contaminated fish by the mothers and to PCB levels in maternal serum and milk rather than to intake during pregnancy. Reproductive disorders have not been described, but the affected male children have not yet reached reproductive age. These studies have been extensively debated, and more investigations in populations with well-known high exposures are needed to resolve this issue.
Levels of some PCB congeners were inversely correlated to sperm motility in semen samples in which sperm concentration was < 20 million/ml (279). The small number of subjects in the study leaves the significance of the finding open. Severe poisoning accidents occurred in Yusho, Japan, and Yu-Cheng, Taiwan, where a large population ate rice oil contaminated with PCBs, PCDFs, and polychlorinated terphenyls. Exposed pregnant women had increased fetal loss and the surviving infants had low birth weight (280). The exposed infants were delayed in their developmental milestones. The behavioral effects were probably mainly due to exposure in utero, since the effects were also found in bottle-fed infants (232). The boys at pubertal age (11 and 14 years of age; n=23) exposed prenatally to very high levels of contaminants had significantly smaller penis lengths when compared to controls, whereas 31 boys at prepubertal age (8 and 10 years of age) did not differ from controls (281). The plasma levels of PCBs in Yusho were originally 0.01 to 0.1 ppm while body fat levels ranged up to 76 ppm. In the normal population the corresponding figures are <0.005 ppm and 0.5 to 10 ppm (282). The reproductive ability of the exposed males has yet to be ascertained.
Dioxins and Furans. Humans are normally exposed to dioxin and furan levels far below those that induce reproductive disorders in animal experiments (206). After the Seveso accident in Italy in 1976 where a factory exploded during the production of 2,4,5-trichlorophenol, TCDD serum levels on a lipid basis ranged from 1770 to 56,660 ppt (ng/kg) in exposed children (283), while the background concentration in human milk fat is approximately 2 ppt (225). No reproductive disorders in adults have been described after the accident (284,285), though the exposed male children have not yet been evaluated.
Recently Found Xenoestrogens
Measurement of human exposure to alkylphenols, phthalate esters and bisphenol-A is difficult because the data are still sparse. There is, however, considerable concern because these compounds are so ubiquitous in the modern environment. Some nonylphenol ethoxylates and one octylphenol ethoxylate were found at concentrations of 15 to 29 ng/liter in drinking water in New Jersey (286). In different fish species, concentrations of 0.13 to 3.1 mg/kg dry weight of nonylphenol and its two ethoxylates have been found (256). Since these compounds have very weak estrogenicity, it is too early to estimate whether environmental exposure to them has any influence on humans, as the level of exposure of man is not known. However, for phthalates it is established that human intake per day is likely to be several hundreds of micrograms per kilogram per day, from certain food sources alone (201). This level of intake would be likely to result in estrogenic effects based on data from in vitro (203) and in vivo (200) studies, though not all phthalates may be estrogenic.
Phytoestrogens
Large amounts (hundreds of milligrams) of phytoestrogens such as isoflavones can be ingested daily by humans, especially in a vegetarian diet. Antiestrogenic action of isoflavones was demonstrated in women who consumed a soy protein-enriched diet containing 45 mg isoflavones daily for 1 month: the follicular phase was prolonged, and the midcycle surge of LH and FSH was suppressed (266,287). This may have occurred because of phytoestrogen-induced production of SHBG, which would reduce bioavailability of endogenously produced estrogens. In postmenopausal women, dietary soy induced no significant estrogenic or antiestrogenic effects (288). SHBG and gonadotropin levels remained unchanged in these women, whereas the vaginal epithelium showed a tendency for a higher percentage of superficial cells (indicative of estrogenicity). A study of postmenopausal women in Australia suggested an estrogenic influence by phytoestrogens on the vaginal epithelium (289). Many infants are fed with soy-based milk-substitute formulas rich in phytoestrogens. There are no data available about the possible endocrine effects in children, but it is presumed that the situation would be radically different from the adult because of the negligible endogenous production of estrogens in infancy (especially in male infants). Female rats exposed neonatally to phytoestrogens show an increased incidence of premature anovulatory syndrome in adult life. This syndrome is recognized as a classical consequence of inappropriate exposure to estrogens in neonatal life (290). Many phytoestrogens, such as lignans and isoflavonoids, are metabolized and excreted in urine similarly to endogenous estrogens (260). Thus, they may not bioaccumulate in the body.
Summary
Humans are exposed to environmental estrogens in multiple ways. Diet, drinking water, air, and the skin are the routes through which xenoestrogens enter the body. Several of the known xenoestrogens have a weak estrogenic activity but are highly persistent and accumulate in fat. Moreover, many of them have additive effects. Some of these compounds, such as phthalates, are present in high concentrations in certain food items, whereas concentrations of pesticides and PCBs are very low. The level of exposure to pesticides and other contaminants is rather well monitored, whereas very little is known about exposure to other xenoestrogens.
Methods for Evaluation of Estrogenlike Effects, Human Exposure to Estrogenic Compounds, and Trends in Male Reproductive Health
The complexity of our chemical environment is increasing continuously, and it may not be possible to forecast all of the effects of compounds released in nature. However, we have to use all the available methods and develop new ones to monitor possible adverse effects of chemicals and natural compounds on human and wildlife. Reproduction is a major concern because disturbances of this process rapidly threaten populations as a whole. The male reproductive system is very sensitive to the influence of an excess of estrogen; therefore, estrogenlike effects in the environment are a primary suspect for causing the increased reproductive disorders of men and wildlife animals.
Test methods are needed to screen chemicals for estrogenic effects. Further methods are needed to assess estrogenic exposure of humans and other species. Methods to analyze the mechanism of action of estrogenic compounds are necessary. And finally, it is important to assess the reproductive toxicity of chemicals and to predict their effects in the environment, including the effects on organisms, populations, communities, and ecosystems.
Epidemiology
The general research question is whether exposure to environmental estrogens, in particular during fetal or neonatal life, has adverse effects on the male reproductive system. When designing epidemiological studies to evaluate this question, one has to consider both exposure and reproductive health outcome. Exposure measurements may sometimes be directly available, e.g., controlled DES treatment during pregnancy, but in most cases such information has to be obtained retrospectively. This, however, may raise difficulties of recall bias and recall uncertainty (often an answer to a general question such as "have you had hormone treatment during pregnancy" will be the only exposure data that can be obtained).
In this situation the so-called ecological approach may be necessary. Rather than relating adverse outcomes to exposure for individuals, this is done for groups. Two general dimensions are used: temporal and spatial. Indeed the temporal trends in selected outcomes have been instrumental in raising the suspicions and concerns described in this report. It is hypothesized that putative exposures do vary considerably along the temporal gradients. Spatial trends have so far been exploited in only a few cases, e.g., Danish-Finnish sperm concentration and testicular cancer incidence (16,21,22), which also illustrates that covariation of outcomes can sometimes be informative when few if any exposure measurements are available. In general we are not aware of much hard evidence to directly support an explanation in terms of specific exposures of the spatial gradients. Sources of variation in the spatial gradient are, for example, ethnic differences, with the associated difficulties in separating genetic, cultural, and socioeconomic gradients from the exposures of our prime interest. In particular, the considerable success from nutritional epidemiology of migrant studies (such as Japanese immigrants to Hawaii or California) might form an inspiration for epidemiological designs for the problem of environmental estrogens.
Turning to outcomes, the original focus was on defects of the male reproductive system. To this we have added specific estrogen responses (gynecomastia, male breast cancer). Schematically, there are advantages and problems (Table 2).
Responses occurring with delay require a long time span for these kinds of reproductive studies. For both prospective and retrospective studies this has negative consequences for both logistics and interpretation (e.g., male breast cancer cases may have to be related to pregnancies 50-70 years ago).
Epidemiological studies are needed to monitor the trends in incidence of testicular cancer and birth defects (cryptorchidism, hypospadias), and changes in semen quality and infertility. Follow-up of semen quality is very important, since the sperm concentration has decreased drastically during the last two generations (5) and the declining trend appears to be continuing (11). Risk factors for testicular cancer have been analyzed in several case-control studies. Estrogen treatment of mothers whose sons have developed testicular cancer has remained an equivocal risk factor. It is unfortunate that there are no prospective studies yet concerning the testicular cancer risk among males exposed to DES. The studies by Bibbo and Gill, and their co-workers (174,291) preceded the time when testicular cancer would have become manifest. Epidemiological studies of the risk factors for poor semen quality and infertility are needed. Furthermore, epidemiological studies should be combined with studies on hormone metabolism when a link between disorder and hormone effect is sought. In women, dietary influence on estrogen metabolism and the risk of breast cancer was analyzed in large epidemiological studies in which both exogenous and endogenous hormones and their metabolites were analyzed meticulously in blood, urine, and feces (292); this provided the basis for the link between high levels of free endogenous estrogen (found in women with Western-type diet) and increased breast cancer risk. There are no comparable studies among men concerning reproductive disorders, although if these disorders are induced in fetal/childhood life but are not manifest until adulthood, then there are large obstacles to deducing any cause-and-effect relationships. "Time to pregnancy" analysis and exposure assessment allow the study of fecundity of exposed males (293).
Ecoepidemiology
Causal relationships between environmental contaminants and specific disease states in wildlife are difficult to obtain because these animals are not living in controlled conditions. An ecoepidemiologal approach to circumvent these problems is to evaluate systematically the relationship between proposed causal agents and specific outcomes. The criteria used to develop causal inference include a) probability, b) time order, c) strength of association, d) specificity, e) consistency on replication, f) predictive performance, and g) coherence [reviewed by Fox (294)]. This approach is often more useful in rejecting a causal relationship than in providing definitive support. However, the use of this systematic approach, well-formed sampling designs, and rigorous statistical analysis can provide us with data useful in risk assessment.
Continuous monitoring of the wildlife populations is needed to detect any disturbances in reproduction. Furthermore, timing and magnitude of chemical exposure should be considered when estrogenic effects are examined.
Experimental Models for Testing Estrogenicity and Estrogenic Molecules
Different approaches can be used to assay estrogenic activity, depending on whether or not the compound is known to have such an activity. In the first case, direct physicochemical analyses, such as gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy or high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), can be used to assess the presence, and if necessary, the concentration of a xenoestrogen(s). Many banned chemicals (e.g., PCBs) can be detected by this method. Specific immunoassays can be used when appropriate antibodies are available. Different approaches must be used when putative estrogenicity of a compound(s) is screened or the cause of a suspected estrogenic contamination is searched for. Binding assays and bioassays are commonly used for this purpose.
The principle of binding assays is to try to displace radiolabeled estradiol from its receptor by increasing molar concentrations of either unlabeled estradiol (reference curve) or different purified xenobiotics to be screened. Biological material used here is either a total extract or a nuclear extract of cells or a tissue containing a high concentration of estrogen receptor (e.g., the rabbit or rat uterus, MCF-7 cells). Binding experiments are very useful, but it should be remembered that binding of a compound does not necessarily imply its biologic activity. Moreover, the concentration of a chemical needed to displace 50% bound [3H]estradiol is orders of magnitude higher than that needed to elicit a biological response.
There are a number of bioassays available for assessment of the estrogenicity of a chemical. These can be divided into two groups: animal models and in vitro models.
Animal Models. A range of different species such as chicken, rat, mouse, trout, and reptiles has been used in estrogenicity testing. The most widely used rodent bioassay measures the increase in uterine weight in the rat (295). However, it is well known that this bioassay gives a crude estimate of an estrogen effect, that it is insensitive, costly, laborious, and cannot be adopted for large-scale screening. Moreover, there is no standard procedure for the uterotropic assays. Instead, different laboratories use different protocols (multiple doses vs single dose, 24 vs 72 hr, etc.). Vitellogenesis in male fish, e.g., trout, can be used to test for the presence of estrogenic compounds in the aquatic environment.
Mammalian animal models. Various laboratory or domestic animal species can be used to address specific aspects of the possible effects in vivo of estrogenic chemicals. These should be particularly useful for studies of delayed effects (i.e., where exposure to the chemical(s)occurs in fetal/neonatal life and the reproductive consequences are manifest in adult life) and for studies of the effects of chronic low-level exposure to xenoestrogens. For example, possible effects of these chemicals on Sertoli cell multiplication can be studied in developing rats or mice by exposing them during gestation and/or during the first 3 postnatal weeks of life (the period of Sertoli cell multiplication extends from day 16 of gestation to postnatal days 15-18 in the rat). Sperm output, fertility, and testis size and morphology can then be evaluated in adult life and Sertoli cell number determined in other animals at around day 18 of postnatal life. In this way, possible chronic effects of low-level exposure to xenoestrogens during development on adult reproductive ability can be evaluated in a fairly simple way. Such studies are ongoing and have already proved that such effects can be detected (200). The importance of these particular studies is that they may provide reference values of harmful exposure (i.e., µg/kg/day) that can then be related to measured levels of exposure in man.
The other main uses of mammalian animal models will be in determining the mechanisms of xenoestrogen-induced disruption of reproductive development. Mice and rats have been used already for some such studies, and probes or antibodies for some of the key genes that are expressed during normal reproductive development are available. Evaluation of the effects of exposure to xenoestrogens at specific times during development on expression of these key genes (or on the effects of the gene products) will obviously be extremely valuable, especially as any changes identified will be able to be related to consequences in adult life.
There is also a need for exploitation of animal models other than rodents, as these have limitations in terms of direct access to the developing male fetus (i.e., exposure is always through the mother). In this respect there is a place for the use of the fetal sheep or pig and the developing opossum. In the former, it is possible to cannulate blood vessels in the fetus at mid-term and to then directly administer a compound to the fetus and to monitor consequences in terms of changes in blood hormone levels (165); for example, this system could be used to determine what blood level of xenoestrogen in the fetus results in reduced secretion of FSH from the pituitary gland and is thus likely to reduce Sertoli cell multiplication (see "Effects of Synthetic Estrogens on the Testis in Animal Models"). In contrast, the opossum provides fairly unique direct access to a fetus that is born before sexual differentiation has occurred. Thus administration of xenoestrogens to the young at this stage (either through the skin or orally) could provide a direct and controlled way of pinpointing when and how such exposure might result in disruption of the normal cascade of male reproductive development; this would enable identification of critical windows of developmental susceptibility to estrogens. It is established already that a) the pathway of development in these animals is comparable to that in eutherian mammals, and b) exposure of the young to estrogens is able to disrupt completely the normal differentiation of the testis and seminiferous cord formation (296).
Vitellogenesis. Vitellogenin is a yolk protein produced normally in the liver of female fish under estrogen control (297). Very little, if any, vitellogenin can be detected in male fish (298). However, exposure to estrogens activates the vitellogenin gene, resulting in increased vitellogenin levels in the blood of male fish, and clear dose-response effects have been documented (299). Vitellogenesis can be used both in field studies and in laboratory in vitro studies (300). It is measured by a specific radioimmunoassay (301). Sex reversal could also be used as an end point for estrogenic effects in an aquatic milieu.
In field studies, caged male rainbow trout are exposed to water in areas of interest, and their vitellogenin levels are followed over time (112). This is a good screening method for the presence of estrogenic compounds in different aquatic habitats. Vitellogenin production by superfused trout hepatocytes can also be used as a sensitive in vitro bioassay for analysis of estrogenic compounds in the water (111).
Fish reproductive tests. The Office of Pollution Prevention and Toxics (OPPT) in the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) is using two fish reproductive assays: a) fish partial chronic toxicity test that measures effects from adult to the early life stage, and b) fish whole life toxicity test that measures effects from egg to early life stage to adult and then to early life stage (OPPTS 850.1500).
Reptile egg assays. Reptile sex differentiation is temperature- and estrogen- dependent (155). Exposure of turtle eggs to a putative xenoestrogen by spotting or painting them with the compound results in a high proportion of feminization or intersex conditions of hatchlings in a temperature that would normally result in 100% males (99). This assay is suitable for studies of estrogen exposure in wildlife.
In Vitro Assays. Two complementary aspects can be studied by in vitro assays: proliferation of an estrogen-dependent cell line, and the induction of an estrogen-controlled function. In the first case, cell number and the incorporation of radiolabeled thymidine are the parameters measured. In the second case (induction of function), there are several possibilities. Prolactin production by pituitary cells in response to an estrogenic compound was an early attempt to measure estrogenic activity in vitro, but the assay was abandoned because of its nonspecificity. For assessment of the estrogenic activity in the aquatic environment, the in vitro assay for detecting vitellogenin in fish is extremely useful (302). At present, the most commonly used mammalian in vitro assays are the MCF-7 cell tests and the recombinant yeast cell assays. Serum that is required in the culture of breast-cancer cell lines must be charcoal-stripped to remove endogenous estrogens.
MCF-7 cell line. Human breast cancer cell lines (MCF-7 cells) that are sensitive to estrogen have been used to screen chemicals for their estrogenic effects (81). The test--also called the E-SCREEN--is based on the dose-response relationship between the proliferation of MCF-7 cells and the amount of estrogen to which the cells are exposed during 6 days of culture. Estradiol is used as a standard. By comparing the effects of a xenoestrogen and estradiol, we can present the relative estrogenic potency of a compound. Soto et al. (81) use the following concepts to describe estrogenicity: "Concentration" denotes the dose at which an estrogenic effect is detected; proliferative efficiency (PE) measures the ratio between the highest cell number in the presence and in the absence of estrogen; relative proliferative efficiency (RPE) measures the ratio between the maximal cell yield achieved by a xenobiotic and that of estradiol; relative proliferative potency (RPP) measures the ratio between the dose of xenobiotic and that of estradiol needed to achieve a proliferative effect. Alkylphenols, pesticides, phytoestrogens, and synthetic estrogens have been analyzed using this test (81,212). Some endocrinologists consider cell proliferation a hallmark of estrogen action; and if a compound does not have this property, regardless of what other end points it influences, it should not be called an estrogen. The E-SCREEN is technically an easy method and can be used for screening and assessment of approximate estrogenic potency of a compound. Other hormones and growth factors tested so far have not influenced this assay (204). However, the possibility remains that some compounds may influence these cells through other than estrogenic pathways and thereby confound the results.
MCF-7 cells were also used to detect the estrogenic effect of bisphenol-A that was released from polycarbonate flasks during autoclaving (267). Progesterone receptor induction and [3H]thymidine incorporation combined with DNA measurement were used to measure estrogen activity (81). This approach covers the proliferative effect (thymidine incorporation) and the change-of-function effect (progesterone receptor induction) of the compound studied. This adds to the technical difficulty and the expense of the assay.
Estrogen effects on MCF-7 cells can also be monitored after transient transfection of cells with reporter plasmids pTKLUC and pERE-TKLUC by assaying for luciferase activity (203). The reporter plasmid pTKLUC contains the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (TK) promoter inserted in the Bgl II site of the luciferase reporter plasmid pGL2-Basic (Promega). pERE-TKLUC contains a single copy of the vitellogenin A2 estrogen response element inserted upstream of the TK promoter in pTKLUC.
ZR-75 cell line. Several human estrogen-responsive cell lines, such as ZR-75, in addition to MCF-7 can be used in cell proliferation assays (203).
Recombinant yeast cell lines. The most sensitive estrogen measurement at the moment is a recombinant cell bioassay comprising a yeast cell line (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) transformed with plasmids encoding the human estrogen receptor and an estrogen-responsive promoter fused to the structural gene for ß-galactosidase (303). This assay detects 100-fold lower estradiol levels than the widely used traditional radioimmunoassays. However, the sensitivity of the assay to other estrogenic hormones than estradiol is lower. This bioassay revealed an 8-fold difference in the estrogen levels of prepubertal boys and girls (303), who were previously believed to have similar hormone concentrations (304). This has important implications for future studies since it is now possible to measure quantitatively increased estrogen levels in prepubertal boys. The assay is simple to perform once the cell line is established since only the measurement of ß-galactosidase activity is needed to observe the effect.
Sensitivity of the Assays. The sensitivity of the assays for measurement of 17ß-estradiol is given in the Table 3.
The recombinant yeast cell assay appears to be the most sensitive of the assays, although the E-SCREEN may not be far behind. Both assays detect estradiol levels that are less than 0.1 pg/ml. Traditional radioimmunoassays with an antibody strictly specific for estradiol had a maximum sensitivity of 2 pg/ml (305). However, sensitivity can be improved to less than 0.1 pg/ml (306). In the E-SCREEN assay, the lowest estradiol level to produce a maximal proliferative effect is 10 pg/ml, but detectable proliferation occurs already at 0.3 pg/ml (307). Activity, significantly different from the unstimulated control, has been detected at 0.03 pg/ml (C Sonnenschein and AM Soto, personal communication). When the ultrasensitive estrogen assays are used, extreme care should be taken in the way the samples (to be analyzed) are handled, stored (quality of plastic vials), and processed, because major problems may be encountered from low levels of contaminating estrogens, e.g., plasticizers leaching from plastic storage tubes, syringes, cell culture plates, etc.
Complementary to these techniques, the binding of the compounds to proteins, such as SHBG and -fetoprotein (AFP), should always be studied in order to address the difficult problem of bioavailability.
In conclusion, although a wide variety of different assays are used (and probably always will be!), in general they have produced very consistent results; that is, a chemical that is estrogenic in one assay is estrogenic in all other assays. For example, alkylphenolic compounds are weakly estrogenic in molecular assays (257), cell proliferation assays (81), and in vitro estrogen-binding assays (203). There appears to be no species specificity; i.e., a chemical that is estrogenic in one animal appears to be estrogenic in all other species. Again, alkylphenolic compounds provide a good example. These chemicals are weakly estrogenic in fish, birds, and mammals (257). This is not at all surprising since the structure of the estrogen receptor is highly conserved between species.
Limitations of in Vitro Testing. Absorption and metabolism of a compound are important for its effects. Because a chemical is, or is not, estrogenic in vitro does not necessarily mean that it will exhibit this activity in vivo. It may not be absorbed. It may be metabolized in the gut to an inactive or nonabsorbable metabolite. Alternatively, a chemical that is nonestrogenic in vitro may be converted to an estrogenic metabolite in either the gut or the liver. This possibility is important as it points out the limitation of in vitro screens (false negatives). Screening of classes of compounds and identification of the chemical structure(s) associated with estrogenicity are obvious ways by which this limitation could be minimized.
Although some proestrogens are supposed to be metabolized into an active form in the liver, and thus they are expected to be inactive in in vitro assays, such compounds (e.g., alkylphenol monoethoxylates, some PCB congeners, methoxychlor) have been found to be estrogenic for MCF-7 cells, suggesting that these cells may also metabolize some chemicals (204,257).
General Reproductive Toxicity Testing
Only a few chemicals have been tested specifically for estrogenic or other endocrine activity. However, many chemicals have been tested for their reproductive toxicity, and thereby indirectly for estrogenicity, although weak estrogenic activity most probably does not appear in these tests. Current toxicity tests are designed primarily to detect overt teratogenic and reproductive effects or toxicity in the adult--they have not been designed to seek out effects where there is a long lag-phase between induction and manifestation of the effect. Moreover, unless such changes were gross and pathological, they would probably be dismissed as insignificant, e.g., small reduction in testis size and sperm count.
Toxicity testing used by U.S. regulatory agencies and by the National Toxicology Program includes three test segments (Segments I-III), Fertility Assessment by Continuous Breeding (FACB), and either two-generation or multigeneration tests (308). Segment I covers fertility and reproductive function in male and female; Segment II deals with developmental toxicology and teratology; and Segment III tests perinatal and postnatal toxicity.
Thus, reproductive toxicity testing belongs to the routine toxicology that has to be undertaken before a new compound can be released to the environment. The problem is that although testing appears extensive, it may miss important late effects and actions that occur only when additive factors are present. The reproductive toxicity tests used in the current safety assessment of various chemicals are discussed in more detail in "Appendix B".
Testicular Cancer Models
There are no animal models for testicular germ cell tumors. This necessitates more intensive search for such a model. Testicular stromal tumors can be produced in mice both by gene deletion (309) and by overexpression of an oncogene under the control of a testis-specific promoter (e.g., inhibin alpha promoter connected to SV 40 large-T antigen). The transgene approach has been used to produce testicular somatic cell tumors from which new testicular cell lines have been developed (K Kananen, personal communication). Direct transformation of germ cells with SV 40 large-T antigen has been used to immortalize spermatogonia (310). When a temperature-sensitive p53 mutant is co-transfected into these cells they were reported to differentiate through meiosis (311). These recombinant cell models may give possibilities for detailed analyses of many features of gene activity and its regulation in specific testicular cell types. Although the cells are transformed, most of their characteristic functions should remain unchanged. Such approaches may be extremely useful in improving our understanding of primordial germ cell development and of the factors that are involved in arrest of development resulting in precancerous carcinoma in situ (CIS) cells.
Brinster and co-workers (312,313) demonstrated that stem cell spermatogonia survived a transit to mouse seminiferous tubules that were either partially or totally missing their own germ cells. The transferred spermatogonia produced normal spermatozoa. Spermatogenic cells survive poorly in vitro, but spermatogonia are the most viable (314-316). This raises the possibility of in vitro experimentation, which can be continued in vivo by injecting cultured spermatogonia back into the seminiferous tubules. Human CIS cells could be transferred to mouse seminiferous tubules (which are an immunologically privileged site) to follow possible carcinogenesis. Endocrine manipulation of recipient animals would enable study of the role of hormones in the promotion of tumor growth.
Summary
Multidisciplinary approaches are needed into studies of environmental effects on male reproductive health. Epidemiological methods should be used to follow up the trends in male reproductive health and to identify putative association to environmental factors. Similarly, ecoepidemiology gives valuable information on concurrent changes in wildlife. Experimental studies in laboratory animals and cell lines provide direct evidence of the effects of xenobiotics. Both physicochemical and biological methods should be used for the identification of estrogenic-/endocrine-disrupting compounds in the environment and for the determination of human exposure to these agents.
General Discussion on the Association between Chemicals in the Environment and Male Reproductive Health
The possibility that exposure of humans and wildlife to environmental estrogenic chemicals might result in adverse changes in reproductive development, function and/or behavior is not particularly new; concern was first expressed two decades ago in relation to DDT. Indeed, the first demonstration that a range of man-made chemicals could be estrogenic when administered to animals stems from 1938 (317). The issue has resurfaced because of two new developments. The first is the increasing appearance in the human population of several adverse changes of the sort that researchers predicted might occur if human exposure to environmental estrogens was widespread. The second has been the discovery of many new environmental estrogens to which we are exposed daily. In light of these developments, the foregoing report has reevaluated the strength of the available information to ascertain whether or not there is real concern for human health stemming from exposure to environmental estrogens, or whether the data are more consistent with a theoretical, but unlikely, effect on the human. The following stepwise conclusions have been reached:
- All of the best evidence available points with some certainty to a rising tide in Europe and many other countries of human male reproductive disorders involving sperm counts (and probably sperm quality), testicular cancer, malformation of the external genitalia, and possibly testicular maldescent.
- There are insufficient data to prove or disprove that these adverse changes in male reproductive health are the result, wholly or partially, of exposure to environmental estrogens. In addressing this issue, we have identified alarming gaps in our knowledge of the route and levels of human exposure to nonpesticide environmental chemicals. Many of these chemicals have not been evaluated for their reproductive toxicity; even where such studies have been performed, their design and intent were such that they may have failed to exclude delayed effects of the sort that can be induced by estrogen (or other hormone) exposure during development.
- If the above changes in male reproductive health do result from fetal and/or neonatal exposure to environmental estrogens, then we will not know what the current prevalence in male children is for another 20 to 40 years. This is due to the delay between induction and manifestation of many of the effects, e.g., lowered sperm counts or the development of testicular cancer in adult life. The indications are that these problems are still increasing in incidence in the general population.
- Based on what is known about the widespread imprinting effects of steroid hormones (androgens and estrogens as well as antagonists of these hormones) when there is exposure during fetal/neonatal development, it is possible that there are other adverse health consequences in man of such exposures of which we are currently unaware, e.g., permanent changes to the immune system, growth, etc.
- There is enough evidence from a variety of sources to suggest that environmental estrogens have the capacity to induce adverse minor and major reproductive defects in man, but there are inadequate data on the level of actual human exposure to these chemicals, which means that no accurate risk assessment can be made. There are also insufficient animal data to permit such an assessment.
- Determination of whether environmental estrogens do exert harmful effects in man will probably have to rely on weight of evidence rather than establishment of precise cause and effect. To provide this evidence as accurately as possible, future work should address the problem at several levels, including epidemiology, laboratory animal studies, wildlife studies, more complete identification of estrogenic chemicals (i.e., screening), and accurate assessment of the routes and levels of human exposure to these chemicals.
- There are substantial differences in the incidence of the reproductive defects, referred to previously, in different countries/races and these also appear to show possible relationships to the incidence of other hormone-dependent diseases of the reproductive system (breast, prostate). The etiology of these differences should be explored to ascertain to what extent they reflect ethnic/genetic, lifestyle, or environmental influences.
- There is an urgent need for a clearer understanding of the hormonal environment of the fetus during the period of male sexual differentiation and development, especially of what mechanisms are present to protect the fetus from maternal estrogens, e.g., -fetoprotein, steroid-metabolizing enzymes, etc. Because of the inaccessibility of the human fetus at this stage, these studies will probably have to be undertaken in animals.
- Investment of resources in obtaining the information necessary to assess whether environmental estrogens pose a health risk to man will have major spin-off in terms of our understanding of fetal and neonatal determinants of disease, the routes and importance of human exposure to nonpesticide environmental chemicals and of the etiology of geographic and ethnic differences in disease.
Suggestion for a Strategy to Strengthen the Evaluation of Hazards of Estrogens or Xenoestrogens
Several lines of evidence have indicated adverse trends in male reproductive health over the last few decades. Clinical and experimental research has demonstrated that the reproductive disorders reported may be interrelated and may have a common origin in fetal life or childhood. Studies of wildlife and human epidemiology suggest that environmental factors are involved in the origin of reproductive disorders. Common environmental contaminants such as alkylphenols and phthalate esters, and natural factors such as phytoestrogens, have been shown to be endocrine-disrupting agents, many of them being estrogenic. Our hypothesis is that the adverse trends in human male reproductive health is, at least in part, associated with exposure to environmental estrogenic compounds during early development. Testing of this hypothesis necessitates a multidisciplinary research approach, including epidemiological and experimental studies, examination of wildlife, and analyses of environmental contaminants and human exposure to them. Extensive international collaboration that combines the existing strengths of various institutions and investigators is probably required if this complex health problem is to be addressed in the most accurate and effective way.
Research Strategy
The proposed research strategy is illustrated schematically in Figure 8 and is expanded upon in the relevant sections below. There are three fundamental components to this strategy (boxed in Figure 8).
Figure 8. Suggestion for a research strategy to strenghten the evaluation of hazards of estrogens or xenoestrogens.
The first component centers on the collection and evaluation of epidemiological evidence for male reproductive disorders in man and animals. The intention of this approach is to define the scale of male reproductive disorders, to establish geographical differences in their distribution and to assess whether there is an increase in incidence of such disorders in groups with known exposure to estrogens or xenoestrogens.
The second and third components of the strategy are designed to identify xenoestrogens using a variety of in vitro screening methods and then to evaluate whether their administration to laboratory animals results in biochemical and biological effects (in vivo screening). This approach would be complemented by studies on the environmental distribution of these chemicals and by assessment of the routes and level of human exposure. This information, in conjunction with the relevant epidemiological evidence, should enable some form of risk assessment to be made for man and for wildlife.
Epidemiological Studies in Man
In epidemiological studies, trends in male reproductive health must be followed up further in different geographic areas and in populations with different ethnic and racial backgrounds. In addition, every attempt should be made to use some of the existing data or cohort studies, if these are appropriate, although in some instances collection of new data is essential.
Incidence of Male Reproductive Disorders in Man. There are geographic and racial variation in semen quality and other aspects of male reproductive function. Semen quality, testis size, levels of sex hormones and gonadotropins as well as presence of cryptorchidism and gynecomastia may all be indicators of abnormal male reproductive function. The aim of the study is to examine geographic and racial differences and to establish reference values for semen quality, blood levels of sex hormones and gonadotropins, testis size, and prevalence of gynecomastia and cryptorchidism, since these conditions may provide us with information on environmental and genetic influences on male reproductive development and function. Furthermore, such studies may be starting points for future prospective studies on secular trends in male reproductive function.
In order to obtain comparable groups of individuals, well-defined types of men should be investigated, such as army recruits and semen donor candidates. The study should involve men from the United States, France, Finland, Denmark, United Kingdom, and possibly Taiwan or Japan, with the final selection of countries to be determined by the study groups.
The following parameters should be assessed:
- semen quality: volume, density, morphology, computerized motility assessment; to ensure a standardization of the methods, the laboratories involved in the project should circulate relevant samples or videotapes
- serum levels of testosterone, estradiol, FSH, and LH
- morphometric measurements: weight, height, testis size
- cryptorchidism
- gynecomastia
- time to pregnancy if the men have reached an age when they have wished to become fathers
The rest of serum and semen samples should be stored in the freezer for possible future analysis for, e.g., environmental pollutants or other relevant parameters.
Denmark and Finland provide an interesting comparison. The incidence of testicular cancer in Denmark is remarkably higher than in Finland (22). Conversely, semen quality seems to be markedly better in Finland compared to Denmark (16). The incidence of testicular cancer is increasing in both countries, whereas less is known about semen quality. The incidence of cryptorchidism in Denmark in 1960 is known from a careful study of 2701 newborns (60). Additional information is available from the doctors' and midwives' notes of 17,767 newborn males during the period 1957 to 1960. No information on possible increase in the incidence of cryptorchidism in Denmark is available and neither is there information on the incidence of other minor malformations of the male external genitalia. There are no large studies on the incidence of cryptorchidism in Finland. According to the hypothesis that testicular cancer, poor semen quality and developmental anomalies in the male reproductive tract are interrelated, we postulate that the incidence of cryptorchidism is higher in Denmark than in Finland and that the prevalence of genital malformations is increasing in newborns.
Follow-up Data on Humans Exposed to Estrogens/Xenoestrogens. There are situations in which exposure of pregnant women to estrogens or estrogenic compounds have been clearly identified. DES treatment in the United States and some countries of Europe or contamination of foodstuffs with PCBs and PCDFs in Japan and Taiwan are such examples.
These situations are true experimental models and maximum effort should be made to collect existing data on the offspring of these women. The following are the possibilities:
- Obtain additional information from men born to mothers who participated in the well-designed DES trial made in the United States in the 1950s (167). There have been more than 300 men in the follow-up studies of these cohorts (174).
- Obtain information from other men born to exposed mothers.
A possibility would be to study brothers of women known to be exposed to DES, as there is probably an increased possibility that they also were exposed to DES. The size of the study group and a paired control group would have to be defined carefully.
- New case-control studies should be done especially for testicular cancer, since, e.g., the DES-exposed males have now reached the age at which the incidence of testicular cancer peaks.
- Taiwanese boys prenatally exposed to PCBs are now in puberty (281). It is proposed to obtain all the available data on the reproductive tract disorders from these men, and later semen analyses when available.
More information is needed on the incidence and trends for genital defects in various countries.
- Attention should be mainly accorded to cryptorchidism, hypospadias, and male breast cancer. This information could be obtained from many, if not all, of the countries in the EU.
- Information from the newborn cohort established in the 1960s in Denmark could also be used to analyze the trends for genital malformations through a new study. The Bristol-coordinated European cohort study which involves large numbers of children in several Western and Eastern European countries will give additional data on these trends.
Risk factors may be shared among many disorders. Mothers of men with testicular cancer were reported to have an increased risk for breast cancer (190), suggesting common risk factors, such as a high estrogen exposure. In national cancer registries, it is possible to analyze the association between testicular cancer and mother's breast cancer in large patient groups, and such a study is ongoing for example in Denmark.
Occupational Studies. Studies on the offspring of women occupationally exposed to xenoestrogens. Comparison between population groups in so-called ecological studies may suffer from various weaknesses, including confounding bias. Also, if the main effect on male reproductive function is due to prenatal exposure, it may be very difficult to determine the causative exposure in any detail because it happened in the distant past. These problems do not indicate that such studies should not be carried out; but it would be important to supplement this evidence with studies of more specific exposures, such as those that occur in certain occupations.
Among the industrial chemicals so far identified as xenoestrogens are certain additives to plastic materials (e.g., alkylphenols, phthalates, bisphenol-A) and some pesticides. It would therefore be of interest to find female occupational groups with known exposures to such compounds. One group of particular interest is greenhouse workers. Because of the enclosed space of greenhouses, pesticide exposure invariably occurs, partly because of percutaneous absorption. Prospective and cross-sectional studies of the male offspring of the female greenhouse workers could then be carried out with emphasis on cryptorchidism and other indicators of adverse effects on reproductive organs.
Epidemiological Studies in Domestic Animals
There is a lack of information on possible secular trends in male reproductive function among domestic animals. Such animals might serve as good models for evaluation of the environmental impact on human male reproduction, although it should be kept in mind that, for breeding of many of these species, individuals with the best reproductive function have been highly selected. Nevertheless, if any adverse trends are still evident, this would provide powerful supporting data for the human studies and might open up new possibilities for identifying causal agents.
The species that might be of interest are the bull, pig, stallion, and dog. The indicators of male reproductive studies are, as in humans, cryptorchidism, hypospadias ,and semen quality. It is well known that dogs develop spermatocytic seminoma and not the classical, premeiotic germ cell-derived seminomas and nonseminomas. It remains to be seen whether such tumors occur among the other species. Available retrospective data (e.g., databases for artificial insemination stations) on reproductive function in these animals should be analyzed. New, prospective studies should be initiated, if suitable studies can be designed and the archival data warrant such investigation. The overall importance of these analyses is that they may indicate whether adverse changes in male reproductive function are unique to man or more prevalent in man.
Wildlife Studies
If environmental estrogens are currently present in biologically significant background concentrations, a survey of wildlife would provide important supportive information concerning possible human risk. One extremely useful biomarker of estrogen exposure is the synthesis of the hepatic protein vitellogenin. This is normally synthesized in the liver of egg-laying females after estrogen stimulation. Synthesis of this protein is usually correlated with seasonal reproductive activity in females but it is not found in males. Numerous laboratory studies, with a variety of wildlife species, have demonstrated that vitellogenin synthesis is stimulated in males after exogenous estrogen treatment. Recent evidence (112) suggests that both caged male trout in English rivers receiving sewage effluent and males of native fish species from various English rivers and from the river Seine in Paris exhibit elevated plasma vitellogenin levels. These data suggest that environmental estrogens exist in these rivers at biologically significant levels. Thus, a survey of male fish, amphibians, reptiles, and birds living in wetland areas would provide a definitive measure of estrogen exposure in this environment.
Fish would provide a very important model system as they transport large quantities of water through gills that are highly vascular. Second, various species feed at differing trophic levels of the food chain, making a comparison among levels possible. Additionally, other species such as frogs, salamanders, turtles, and alligators or crocodiles could be used, depending on the ecological knowledge base for such species and the specific questions to be addressed. For example, many fish and amphibian species are short lived and are limited to specific water bodies whereas other fish, turtles, and alligators are long lived and may migrate between various wetland areas.
We would propose that a series of rivers, lakes, and marshlands be examined in Europe and North America. If possible, a few common species from similar genera should be examined to minimize interspecies variation. However, as the relative sensitivities of various species are unknown, this survey should examine species that occur in large numbers. Detailed sampling should be designed and similar protocols used. In addition to vitellogenin, plasma androgens and estrogens should be examined to ensure that natural estrogens are not elevated in those males that exhibit a positive response for plasma vitellogenin. These data would also provide supporting evidence of abnormal reproductive activity as previous studies have demonstrated abnormal steroidogenesis following exposure to various contaminants.
The limitation of this study, as presented, is the need for antibodies that recognize vitellogenin from the various species of interest. Vitellogenin is a large, globular protein, approximately 400 to 500 kD, with a complex, three-dimensional structure. Currently, a universal antibody that would cross-react with the vitellogenin of all oviparous species is not available but a number of laboratories are presently developing and screening possible candidates. Collaboration with these laboratories should be fostered. However, if a universal assay is not possible, other methods such as polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) can be used to detect plasma vitellogenin, although this technique would provide poor quantification of plasma concentrations as compared to a validated radioimmunoassay. An additional limitation of this survey involves the specificity of vitellogenin as an estrogen-induced product. A survey for vitellogenin will not detect possible antiandrogens or antiestrogens in the environment. Additional assays for other biomarkers may be required, although the plasma steroid analyses performed simultaneously with vitellogenin assays may provide clues to reproductive abnormalities due to other mechanisms of endocrine disruption.
Surveys need to be performed on a series of wetlands that represent a continuum in water quality. Sites with known contamination will serve as positive controls, whereas other localities with reduced input of manmade chemical contaminants can serve as negative controls. One point of caution should be made concerning the negative control localities--areas perceived as being pristine, such as arctic and antarctic regions, are known to have animal and human populations with elevated body burdens of various persistent environmental contaminants. Thus, it is important that representative species be examined from each test locality for persistent contaminants (e.g., DDE, total PCBs, dioxin). These measurements of contaminant load should not be used as a measure of possible estrogenic contamination, but rather as a general measure of possible environmental pollution. Initial surveys should examine as many male fish as possible (n=~100 males/wetland). Blood samples would be collected rapidly for analysis of vitellogenin, androgens, and estrogens. Specific body characteristics should be noted such as size, body weight, and other descriptive morphometric characteristics. For alligators or other wildlife having phallic structures, measurements of size and developmental abnormalities should be noted.
Experimental Studies --in Vitro and in Vivo Screening
The action of estrogenic chemicals, especially during fetal development in most species, is, in part, determined by their relative binding with intracellular targets and extracellular binding proteins. Estrogenic chemicals with relatively poor binding to extracellular proteins, such as SHBG and AFP, would be expected to have a disproportionate effect on developing estrogen target tissues. This is the case for DES. Experiments are proposed to evaluate the micropharmacokinetics of a selected group of priority environmental agents with estrogenic activity with regard to distribution within both the maternal and fetal compartments. Care must be given as to selection of the appropriate animal model with special regard to endogenous estrogen levels and binding components. As an example, an early step would be to study the relative binding in vitro of selected chemicals to SHBG, AFP, and the estrogen receptor.
To understand the etiology of estrogen-associated developmental abnormalities that may be related to later disease or dysfunction, it is crucially important to study the ontogeny of estrogen responsiveness in target tissues associated with reproduction in appropriate animal models. In addition to whole-animal studies, experiments should be attempted in organ and cell cultures of fetal genital and gonadal tissues; additionally, studies with transgenic mice would be illustrative. These studies should certainly include or emphasize the ontogeny and regulation of the estrogen receptor and related signaling molecules. This information would help to predict which chemicals would most likely alter sexual development and provide strategies for prevention.
Estrogenic chemicals can alter male reproduction through chronic or acute mechanisms. Long-term exposure to these chemicals during fetal/neonatal life can alter the expression of various other hormones, leading to impaired development of the testis such that the capacity for sperm production in adult life is irreversibly reduced. Direct effects on the adult testis that interfere with sperm production are also possible, although less likely. On the other hand, hormonally active xenobiotics can alter a process or expression of a gene during a short window of susceptibility that has long-lasting consequences. Characterization in detail of these later consequences is recommended. There are a few key genes involved in the development of the reproductive tract and gonads, and these provide important targets for study. For example, the effect of estrogen on the expression, regulation, and structure of SRY, Wilm's tumor gene (WT-1), MIS, MIS receptor, growth factor receptors and their ligands, estrogen receptor, genes for steroidogenic and steroid-metabolizing enzymes, and homeotic genes and related genes should be determined.
The class of chemicals called environmental estrogens comprises a diverse group of molecules. Studies to determine the metabolism, distribution, bioaccumulation, and excretion of representative members of this functional class in adult, pregnant, and fetal systems (both in vivo and in vitro) are proposed. This also includes identification of their active estrogenic forms. These data are important to make accurate exposure estimates for susceptible target tissues in the human fetus.
The incidence of testicular cancer in humans is still increasing while its etiology is still unknown. A plausible hypothesis is that estrogenic exposure early in testicular development is associated with later germ cell neoplasia in humans. Studies to elucidate molecular and morphological markers for testicular development are needed. The cell type at risk for neoplastic transformation should also be studied and the process determined. Creative application of modern molecular biological and cell biological techniques should be considered to establish the malignant cell lines. Targeting germ cell-specific gene promoters for transgenic approaches to specific cell transformation and the development of new animal models to study should be encouraged. Studies on the physiology and pathophysiology of estrogens in developing and adult male germ cells are needed to evaluate the role of estrogens in testicular neoplasia. Attention should be given to new experimental models, such as the pig and nonhuman primates.
In order to improve the safety assessment of environmental chemicals, it should be assured that future toxicological testing used for the generation of safety data adequately takes into account the possible detrimental effects on male reproduction of chemicals possessing estrogenic and/or otherwise endocrine-disrupting activity. This probably necessitates the development of new test strategies. It is anticipated that the goal can be achieved by combining modifications of existing protocols for reproductive toxicity testing with the introduction of new in vitro and in vivo assays. The strategy should be based on insight into the mechanisms of action as currently known and emerging from future research activities. The development of improved methods should be an international collaborative effort to obtain worldwide acceptance of their possible use in regulatory safety assessments.
The exposure to possible xenoestrogens should be considered in far more detail than currently practiced in such studies. Methods should be elaborated that address the following questions:
- What chemicals are man (and wildlife) exposed to, by which routes, and to what degree?
- Do these chemicals actually get absorbed (they will not cause effects if they are not absorbed)?
- What are the concentrations of these chemicals in man (and wildlife)? Do any of them accumulate?
- How are these chemicals distributed in the body? Are they mobilized (redistributed) in certain states, such as pregnancy?
- How are they metabolized? Is it the metabolites, rather than the parent compounds, that are of concern? For example, alkylphenol polyethoxylates (a group of surfactants) are not estrogenic, but their degradation products are.
- If humans (and wildlife) are exposed simultaneously to a mixture of estrogenic, and/or antiestrogenic, anti-androgenic, or otherwise endocrine disrupting compounds, rather than to an individual chemical, would the overall effect be diminished or enhanced (additivity, synergism, antagonism)?
Presently we do not have adequate answers (or even preliminary answers in some cases) to any of these questions, mainly because we do not know what chemicals are of the greatest concern.
A major emphasis should be placed on how to identify priority compounds that justify examination (in addition to those already identified as estrogens). The aim would be to test for estrogenic activity of the chemicals to which man (and probably wildlife) is exposed the most.
The usefulness of various sources of information should be explored, such as existing product registers and OECD data on high-volume chemicals. In addition, advice and help may be obtained from industry, which may be able to assist in identifying the more important chemicals.
Collectively, these approaches should enable identification of the major man-made chemicals. These chemicals could then be screened to determine whether they possess any endocrine-disrupting activity. If no effect is observed, the significance of the compound (as far as this context is concerned) is likely to be trivial. If effects are observed, more detailed studies, including dose-response studies on animals, should be undertaken. If the results of these studies raise concern, further metabolic studies, such as accumulation in the body and access to the fetus, would provide further information and enable a better extrapolation to the human situation.
Conclusions
Male reproductive health has received remarkably little attention considering that subfertility affects 5% or more of men and that prostatic hypertrophy or cancer is a major problem for older men. It is now evident that several aspects of male reproductive health have changed dramatically for the worse over the past 30 to 50 years. The most fundamental change has been the striking decline in sperm counts in the ejaculate of normal men; recent evidence from Paris indicates that this decrease amounts to about 2% per year over the last two decades. The result is that many otherwise normal men now have sperm counts so low that their fertility is likely to be impaired. Over the last half-century, the incidence of testicular cancer has increased progressively in many countries to become now the most common cancer in young men. Other disorders of the male reproductive tract may also be increasing in incidence, with several European countries reporting a progressive rise in hypospadias (a malformation of the external genitalia) and an apparently emerging trend toward an increasing incidence of testicular maldescent.
These observations suggest that male reproductive health has declined progressively since the Second World War as a result of changes in environmental or lifestyle factors. While the etiologies underlying these apparent changes are currently unclear, both clinical and laboratory research suggests that all of the described changes in male reproductive health appear interrelated and may have a common origin in fetal life or childhood. This means that the increase in some of the disorders seen today originated 20 to 40 years ago, and the prevalence of such defects in male babies born today will not become manifest for another 20 to 40 years or more.
Trends in the reproductive health of species other than man also raise the possibility of environmental factors as partial etiologic contributions in a decline noted in male reproductive health of wildlife. For example, wild panthers in the United States have been reported to have an increase in undescended testes and a decrease in semen quality, whereas male alligators in some lakes in Florida have been shown to have abnormalities in their sex hormone levels (tending toward femaleness) and to have smaller than normal genitalia. Male fish in some parts of the United Kingdom have been shown to express a femalelike response when studied in a relatively natural setting. Earlier studies of fish-eating birds in the United States demonstrated nests containing male hatchlings that were apparently feminized. A recent report of lactating male fruit bats suggested that the males were, in some way, exposed to a female sex hormone. Recent laboratory studies showed that when estrogenic forms of PCBs were painted on turtle eggs, the male hatchlings were sex-reversed to females. Taken together, this growing body of evidence suggests that environmental factors that resemble female sex hormones may be having an adverse effect on the reproductive capacity and well being of diverse species.
It has been well established that exposure of the male fetus to supranormal levels of estrogens can result in many, if not all, of the reproductive defects referred to earlier. Experiments in which potent synthetic estrogens, such as DES, were given to pregnant laboratory animals have demonstrated that prenatal exposure to synthetic estrogens results in a spectrum of adverse effects on the male offspring including undescended testes, testicular cancer, decreased semen quality, epididymal cysts, hypospadias, and poor fertility. Men similarly exposed in utero to DES have been reported to display related abnormalities such as cryptorchidism, lower sperm counts, cysts of the epididymis, and initially decreased fertility. The wealth of experimental results and associated clinical reports suggests strongly that prenatal exposure to exogenous estrogens may play an etiologic role in the trends observed in human male reproductive health.
The growing number of reports demonstrating that common environmental contaminants and natural factors possess estrogenic activity presents the working hypothesis that the adverse trends in human male reproductive health may be, at least in part, associated with exposure to estrogenic environmental chemicals during fetal and childhood development. The reproductive health trends in men are consistent with this hypothesis. While exposure levels to estrogenic chemicals are not at all well known for humans, the large number of chemicals in numerous environmental categories suggests adequate availability. For example, environmental chemicals reported to be estrogenic include, but are not limited to, some ubiquitous chlorinated hydrocarbons, such as PCBs and DDT; some products of detergent and surfactant manufacture, such as the alkylphenols; and some products released from plastics such as bisphenol-A and some phthalates. Many other compounds in our natural and synthetic environment demonstrate estrogenic activities and more are being discovered as the search continues. Although not the subject of this report, in considering and evaluating the possible role of estrogenic chemicals in male reproductive disorders, it should not be forgotten that many chemicals may have a detrimental effect on male reproductive health through mechanisms other than an estrogenic effect.
The reproductive health trends for men, the emerging data from wildlife, the well-controlled experimental data with developmental exposure to estrogens, and the less well-studied, but consistent, data on human cohorts, as well as the growing knowledge concerning hormonally active environmental chemicals, all point in the same direction. We conclude that these issues, taken in toto, indicate the need for a vigorous research effort to understand the extent of the problem, its underlying etiology, and the development of a strategy for prevention and intervention. Since the health research issues involved are complex and multifactorial and since these issues apparently involve research needs in many disciplines, countries and, indeed, species, this report outlines a multinational, interdisciplinary research effort involving academic, government, and industrial scientists and comprising field and clinical studies, epidemiological research, and basic and applied laboratory research with a comprehensive view to the relationships that will evolve. We consider that this approach will optimize the existing strengths of various institutions and investigators on a worldwide basis and will be the most cost-effective use of fiscal and intellectual resources.
There are many research needs in this area; a detailed description of these needs and strategies to fill them are considered in the full report. In addition to key basic, clinical, and epidemiological studies, the highest priorities go to investigations to fill crucial data gaps necessary to make informed decisions about the risk these chemicals may pose to human health. The most pressing areas of need are reliable estimates of exposure of humans to estrogenic chemicals at different ages including fetal life, and of how the exposures relate to adverse effects on the reproductive system; use of animal models to identify what levels of exposure to estrogenic chemicals do, and what levels do not, impair reproductive development; more penetrating studies of the molecular events that lead to impaired spermatogenesis and testicular cancer; improved studies on the structural and analytical chemistry of chemicals with special emphasis on the prediction of estrogenic activity from the molecular structure of a chemical; and the development of rapid in vitro and in vivo test systems for the detection of estrogenic potency of environmental chemicals and the harmonization of these screening tests with improved techniques for quick, reliable analysis of this chemical class. The proposed high-priority research will help provide the information necessary for appropriate risk assessments.
References
1. DEPA. Miloprojekt Nr. 290. Copenhagen:Danish Environmental Protection Agency, 1995.
2. Nelson CMK, Bunge RG. Semen analysis: evidence for changing parameters of male fertility potential. Fertil Steril 25:503-507 (1974).
3. Leto S, Frensilli FJ. Changing parameters of donor semen. Fertil Steril 36:766-770 (1981).
4. Bostofte E, Serup J, Rebbe H. Has the fertility of Danish men declined through the years in terms of semen quality? A comparison of semen qualities between 1952 and 1972. Int J Fertil 28:91-95 (1983).
5. Carlsen E, Giwercman A, Keiding N, Skakkebæk NE. Evidence for decreasing quality of semen during past 50 years. Br Med J 305:609-613 (1992).
6. Farrow S. Falling sperm quality: fact or fiction? Br Med J 309:1-2 (1994).
7. Bromwich P, Cohen J, Stewart I, Walker A. Decline in sperm counts: an artefact of changed reference range of "normal"? Br Med J 309:19-22 (1994).
8. Keiding N, Giwercman A, Carlsen E, Skakkebæk NE. Falling sperm quality [letter]. Br Med J 309:131 (1994).
9. Skakkebæk NE, Keiding N. Changes in semen and the testis. Br Med J 309:1316-1317 (1994).
10. MacLeod J, Wang Y. Male fertility potential in terms of semen quality: a review of the past, a study of the present. Fertil Steril 31:103-116 (1979).
11. Auger J, Kunstmann JM, Czyglik F, Jouannet P. Decline in semen quality among fertile men in Paris during the past 20 years. N Engl J Med 332:281-285 (1995).
12. Irvine S, Cawood E, Richardson D, MacDonald E, Aitken J. Evidence of deteriorating semen quality in the United Kingdom: birth cohort study in 577 men in Scotland over 11 years. Br Med J 312:467-471 (1996).
13. Van Waeleghem K, De Clercq N, Vermeulen L, Schoonjans F, Comhaire F. Deterioration of sperm quality in young healthy Belgian men. Hum Reprod 11:325-329 (1996).
14. Ginsburg J, Hardiman P. Decreasing quality of semen. Br Med J 305:1229 (1992).
15. Bujan L, Mansar A, Pontonnier F, Mieusset R. Time series analysis of sperm concentration in fertile men in Toulouse, France between 1977 and 1992. Br Med J 312:471-473 (1996).
16. Suominen J, Vierula M. Semen quality of Finnish men. Br Med J 306:1579 (1993).
17. Forman D, Møller H. Testicular cancer. Cancer Surv 19/20:323-341 (1994).
18. Nethersell ABW, Drake LK, Sikora K. The increasing incidence of testicular cancer in East Anglia. Br J Cancer 50:377-380 (1984).
19. Pike MC, Chilvers CED, Bobrow LG. Classification of testicular cancer in incidence and mortality statistics. Br J Cancer 56:83-85 (1987).
20. Boyle P, Kaye SB, Robertson AG. Changes in testicular cancer in Scotland. Eur J Cancer Clin Oncol 23:827-830 (1987).
21. Hakulinen T, Andersen A, Malker B, Pukkala E, Schou G, Tulinius H. Trends in cancer incidence in the Nordic countries. Acta Pathol Microbiol Immunol Scand (Suppl) 288:1-151 (1986).
22. Adami H, Bergström R, Möhner M, Zatonski W, Storm H, Ekbom A, Tretli S, Teppo L, Ziegler H, Rahu M, Gurevicius R, Stengrevics A. Testicular cancer in nine northern European countries. Int J Cancer 59:33-38 (1994).
23. Stone JM, Cruickshank DG, Sandeman TF, Matthews JP. Trebling of the incidence of testicular cancer in Victoria, Australia: 1950-1985. Cancer 68:211-219 (1991).
24. Pearce N, Sheppard RA, Howard JK, Fraser J, Lilley BM. Time trends and occupational differences in cancer of the testis in New Zealand. Cancer 59:1677-1682 (1987).
25. Wilkinson TJ, Colls BM, Schluter PJ. Increased incidence of germ cell testicular cancer in New Zealand Maoris. Br J Cancer 65:769-771 (1992).
26. Sptiz MR, Sider JG, Pollack ES, Lynch HK, Newell GR. Incidence and descriptive features of testicular cancer among United States whites, blacks, and hispanics: 1973-1982. Cancer 58:1785-1790 (1986).
27. Harris LE, Steinberg AG. Abnormalities observed during the first six days of life in 8,716 live-born infants. Pediatrics 14:314-326 (1954).
28. McIntosh R, Merritt KK, Richards MR, Samuels MH, Bellows MT. The incidence of congenital malformations: a study of 5,964 pregnancies. Pediatrics 14:505-521 (1954).
29. McDonald AD. Maternal health and congenital defect. N Engl J Med 258:767-773 (1958).
30. Pitt DB. A study of congenital malformations. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 2:23-30 (1962).
31. Scorer CG. The descent of the testis. Arch Dis Child 39:605-609 (1964).
32. Halevi HS. Congenital malformations in Israel. Br J Prev Soc Med 21:66-77 (1967).
33. Mital VK, Garg BK. Undescended testicle. Indian J Pediatr 39:171-174 (1972).
34. Heinonen OP, Slone D, Shapiro S. Birth Defects and Drugs in Pregnancy. Littleton:Publishing Sciences Group, 1977.
35. Mau G, Schnakenburg Kv. Maldescent of the testes--an epidemiological study. Eur J Pediatr 126:77-84 (1977).
36. Czeizel A, Erödi E, Tóth J. An epidemiological study on undescended testis. J Urol 126:524-527 (1981).
37. Hirasing RA, Grimberg R, Hirasing HD. De frequentie van niet normaal ingedaalde testes bij jonge kinderen. Ned T Geneesk 126:2294-2296 (1982).
38. Hsieh J-T, Huang T-S. A study on cryptorchidism. J Formos Med Assoc 84:953-959 (1985).
39. Matlai P, Beral V. Trends in congenital malformations of external genitalia. Lancet i:108 (1985).
40. Seddon JM, Savory L, Scott-Conner C. Cryptorchidism: the role of medical education in diagnosis. South Med J 78:1201-1204 (1985).
41. Campbell DM, Webb JA, Hargreave TB. Cryptorchidism in Scotland. Br Med J 295:1237-1238 (1987).
42. Morley R, Lucas A. Undescended testes in low birthweight infants. Br Med J 295:753 (1987).
43. Swerdlow AJ, Melzer D. The value of England and Wales congenital malformation notification scheme data for epidemiology: male genital tract malformations. J Epidemiol Community Health 42:8-13 (1988).
44. Choi H, Kim KM, Koh SK, Kim KS, Woo YN, Yoon JB, Choi SK, Kim SW. A survey of externally recognizable genitourinary anomalies in Korean newborns. J Kor Med Sci 4:13-21 (1989).
45. Benson RCJ, Beard CM, Kelalis PP, Kurland LT. Malignant potential of the cryptorchid testis. Mayo Clin Proc 66:372-378 (1991).
46. Correy JF, Newman NM, Collins JA, Burrows EA, Burrows RF, Curran JT. Use of prescription drugs in the first trimester and congenital malformations. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaec 31:340-344 (1991).
47. Ansell PE, Bennett V, Bull D, Jackson MB, Pike LA, Pike MC, Chilvers CED, Dudley NE, Gough MH, Griffiths DM, Redman C, Wilkinson AR, Macfarlane A, Coupland CAC. Cryptorchidism: a prospective study of 7500 consecutive male births: 1984-1988. Arch Dis Child 67:892-899 (1992).
48. Berkowitz GS, Lapinski RH, Dolgin SE, Gazella JG, Bodian CA, Holzman IR. Prevalence and natural history of cryptorchidism. Pediatrics 92:44-49 (1993).
49. Williams P. The imperfectly migrated testis. Lancet i:426-427 (1936).
50. Johnson WW. Cryptorchidism. JAMA 113:25-27 (1939).
51. Baumrucker GO. Incidence of testicular pathology. Bull U S Army Med Depart 5:312-314 (1946).
52. Ward B, Hunter WM. The absent testicle. Br Med J 5179:110-111 (1960).
53. Panayotou PC. The incidence of undescended testis in boys attending elementary schools in Greece. Br J Clin Pract 19:501-507 (1965).
54. Cour-Palais IJ. Spontaneous descent of the testicle. Lancet i:1403-1405 (1966).
55. Blom K. Undescended testis and the time of spontanous descent in 2516 schoolboys. Ugeskr Laeger 146:616-617 (1984).
56. Onuora VC, Evbuomwan I. Abnormal findings associated with undescended testis in Nigerian children. Indian J Pediatr 56:509-511 (1989).
57. Yücesan S, Dindar H, Olcay I, Okur H, Kilicaslan S, Ergören Y, Tüysüz C, Koca M, Civilo B, En IS. Prevalence of congenital abnormalities in Turkish school children. Eur J Epidemiol 9:373-380 (1993).
58. Chilvers C, Pike MC, Forman D, Fogelman K, Wadsworth MEJ. Apparent doubling of frequency of undescended testis in England and Wales in 1962-1981. Lancet ii:330-332 (1984).
59. Thorup J, Cortes D. The incidence of maldescended testes in Denmark. Pediatr Surg Int 5:2-5 (1990).
60. Buemann B, Henriksen H, Villumsen ÅL, Westh Å, Zachau-Christiansen B. Incidence of undescended testis in the newborn. Acta Chir Scand (Suppl) 283:289-293 (1961).
61. Hohlbein R. Mißbildungsfrequenz in Dresden. Zentralbl Gynäkol 18:719-731 (1959).
62. Sweet RA, Schrott HG, Kurland R, Culp OS. Study of the incidence of hypospadias in Rochester, Minnesota, 1940-1970, and a case-control comparison of possible etiologic factors. Mayo Clin Proc 49:52-58 (1974).
63. Czeizel A. Increasing trends in congenital malformations of male external genitalia. Lancet i:462-463 (1985).
64. Czeizel A, Tóth J, Czvenits E. Increased birth prevalence of isolated hypospadias in Hungary. Acta Paediatr Hung 27:329-337 (1986).
65. Källén B, Winberg J. An epidemiological study of hypospadias in Sweden. Acta Paediatr Scand (Suppl) 293:1-21 (1982).
66. Källén B, Bertollini R, Castilla E, Czeizel A, Knudsen LB, Martinez-Frias ML, Mastroiacovo P, Mutchinick O. A joint international study on the epidemiology of hypospadias. Acta Paediatr Scand (Suppl) 324:5-52 (1986).
67. World Health Organization. Congenital Malformations Worldwide: A Report from the International Clearinghouse for Birth Defects Monitoring Systems. Oxford:Elsevier, 1991.
68. Bjerkedal T, Bakketeig LS. Surveillance of congenital malformations and other conditions of the newborn. Int J Epidemiol 4:31-36 (1975).
69. Avellán L. The incidence of hypospadias in Sweden. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg 9:129-139 (1975).
70. Wallace HM, Baumgartner L, Rich H. Congenital malformations and birth injuries in New York City. Pediatrics 12:525-535 (1953).
71. Chung CS, Myrianthopoulos NC, Yoshizaki H. Racial and prenatal factors in major congenital malformations. Am J Hum Genet 20:44-60 (1968).
72. Shapiro RN, Eddy W, Fitzgibbon J, O'Brien G. The incidence of congenital anomalies discovered in the neonatal period. Am J Surg 96:396-400 (1958).
73. Finley WH, Gustavson K-H, Hall TM, Hurst DC, Bargainer CM, Wiedmeyer JA. Birth defects surveillance: Jefferson County, Alabama and Uppsala County, Sweden. South Med J 87:440-445 (1994).
74. Leung TJ, Baird PA, McGillivray B. Hypospadias in British Columbia. Am J Med Genet 21:39-48 (1985).
75. Lowry RB, Thunem NY, Silver M. Congenital anomalies in American Indians of British Colombia. Gen Epidemiol 3:455-467 (1986).
76. Hautau ER. Congenital malformations in infants born to Michigan residents in 1958. J Mich State Med Soc 59:1833-1836 (1960).
77. Davis DL, Bradlov HL, Wolff M, Woodruff T, Hoel DG, Anton-Culver H. Medical hypothesis: xenoestrogens as preventable causes of breast cancer. Environ Health Perspect 101:372-377 (1993).
78. Ewertz M, Holmberg L, Karialainen S, Tretli S, Adami H-O. Incidence of male breast cancer in Scandinavia: 1943-1982. Int J Cancer 43:27-31 (1989).
79. Colborn T, vom Saal FS, Soto AM. Developmental effects of endocrine-disrupting chemicals in wildlife and humans. Environ Health Perspect 101:378-384 (1993).
80. Colborn T, Clement C, Colborn T, Clement C, eds. Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection. Princeton: Princeton Scientific,1992.
81. Soto AM, Chung KL, Sonnenschein C. The pesticides endosulfan, toxaphene, and dieldrin have estrogenic effects on human estrogen-sensitive cells. Environ Health Perspect 102:380-383 (1994).
82. Smith BS. Reproductive anomalies in stenoglossan snails caused by antifouling bottom paints. J Appl Toxicol 1:15-21 (1981).
83. Bryan GW, Gibbs PE, Hummerstone LG, Burt GR. The decline of the gastropod Nucella lapillus around south-west England: evidence for the effect of tributyltin from antifouling paints. J Mar Biol Assoc UK 66:611-640 (1986).
84. Short JW, Rice SD, Brodersen CC, Stickle WB. Occurrence of tri-N-butyltin caused imposex in the North Pacific marine snail Nucella lima in Auke Bay, Alaska. Mar Biol 102:291-297 (1989).
85. Ellis DV, Pattisina LA. Widespread neogastropod imposex: a biological indicator of global TBT contamination. Mar Pollut Bull 21:248-253 (1990).
86. Fox GA. Epidemiological and pathobiological evidence of contaminant-induced alterations in sexual development in free-living wildlife. In: Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection, Vol 23 (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:147-158 (1992)
87. Evans SM, Hutton A, Kendall MA, Samosir AM. Recovery in populations of dogwhelks Nucella lapillus (L) suffering from imposex. Mar Pollut Bull 22:409-413 (1991).
88. Clark DR. Difocol (Kelthane) as an Environmental Contaminant. Washington:U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 1990.
89. Bitman J, Cecil HC, Harris SJ, Fries GF. Estrogenic activity of o,p´-DDT in the mammalian uterus and avian oviduct. Science 162:371-372 (1968).
90. Jennings ML, Percival HF, Woodward AR. Evaluation of alligator hatchlings and egg removal from three Florida lakes. Proc Ann Conf Southeast Assoc Fish Wildl Agencies 42:283-294 (1988).
91. Guillette LJJ. Endocrine-disrupting environmental contaminants and reproduction: lessons from the study of wildlife. In: Women's Health Today: Perspectives on Current Research and Clinical Practice (Popkin DR, Peddle LJ, eds). New York:Parthenon, 1994;201-207.
92. Guillette LJJ, Gross TS, Masson GR, Matter JM, Percival HF, Woodward AR. Developmental abnormalities of the gonad and abnormal sex hormone concentrations in juvenile alligators from contaminated and control lakes in Florida. Environ Health Perspect 102:680-688 (1994).
93. Guillette LJJ, Gross TS, Gross DA, Rooney AA, Percival HF. Gonadal steroidogenesis in vitro from juvenile alligators obtained from contaminated or control lakes. Environ Health Perspect 103(Suppl 4): 31-36 (1995).
94. Bull JJ. Sex determination in reptiles. Q Rev Biol 55:3-21 (1980).
95. Bull JJ, Gutzke WHN, Crews D. Sex reversal by estradiol in three reptilian orders. Gen Comp Endocrinol 70:425-428 (1988).
96. Gutzke WHN, Bull JJ. Steroid hormones reverse sex in turtles. Gen Comp Endocrinol 64:368-372 (1986).
97. Guillette LJJ, Crain DA, Rooney AA, Pickford DB. Organization versus activation: the role of endocrine-disrupting contaminants (EDCs) during embryonic development in wildlife. Environ Health Perspect 103(Suppl 7):157-164 (1995).
98. Guillette LJJ, Pickford DB, Crain DA, Rooney AA, Percival HF. Reduction in penis size and plasma testosterone concentrations in juvenile alligators living in a contaminated environment. Gen Comp Endocrinol 101:32-42 (1996).
99. Bergeron JM, Crews D, McLachlan JA. PCBs as environmental estrogens: turtle sex determination as a biomarker of environmental contamination. Environ Health Perspect 102:780-781 (1994).
100. Munkittrick KR, Port CB, Van Der Kraak GJ, Smith IR, Rokosh DA. Impact of bleached kraft mill effluent on population characteristics, liver MFO activity, and serum steroid levels of a Lake Superior white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) population. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 48:1371-1380 (1991).
101. Andersson T, Forlin L, Harig I, Larsson A. Physiological disturbances in fish living in coastal water polluted with bleached kraft mill effluents. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 45:1525-1536 (1988).
102. Howell WM, Black DA, Bortone SA. Abnormal expression of secondary sex characters in a population of mosquitofish, Gambusia affinis holbrooki: evidence for environmental-induced masculinization. Copeia 4:676-681 (1980).
103. Howell WM, Denton TE. Gonopodial morphogenesis in female mosquitofish, Gambusia affinis affinis, masculinized by exposure to degraded products from plant sterols. Environ Biol Fish 24:43-51 (1989).
104. Owens JW. The hazard assessment of pulp and paper effluents in the aquatic environment: a review. Environ Toxicol Chem 10:1511-1540 (1991).
105. Leatherland JF. Endocrine and reproductive function in Great Lakes salmon. In: Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection. (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:129-145 (1992).
106. Freeman HC, Sangalang GB, Flemming B. The sublethal effects of polychlorinated biphenyl (Aroclor 1254) diet on the Atlantic cod Gadus morhua. Sci Total Environ 24:1-11 (1982).
107. Freeman HC, Sangalang GB, Uthe JF. The effects of pollutants and contaminants on steroidogenesis in fish and marine mammals. Adv Environ Sci Technol 16:197-211 (1984).
108. Turscott B, Walsh J, Burton M, Payne J, Idler D. Effect of acute exposure to crude oil petroleum on some reproductive hormones in salmon and flounder. Comp Biochem Physiol 75C:121-130 (1983).
109. Leatherland JF, Sonstegard RA. Bioaccumulation of organochlorines by yearling coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch Walbaum) fed diets containing Great Lakes coho salmon, and the pathophysiological responses of the recipients. Comp Biochem Physiol 72C:91-99 (1982).
110. Morrison PA, Leatherland JF, Sonstegard RA. Plasma cortisol and sex steroid levels in Great Lakes coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch Walbum) in relation to fecundity and egg survival. Comp Biochem Physiol 80A:61-68 (1985).
111. Jobling S, Sumpter JP. Detergent components in sewage effluent are weakly oestrogenic to fish: an in vitro study using rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) hepatocytes. Aquatic Toxicol 27:361-372 (1993).
112. Purdom CE, Hardiman PA, Bye VJ, Eno NC, Tyler CR, Sumpter JP. Estrogenic effects of effluents from sewage treatment works. Chem Ecol 8:275-285 (1994).
113. Bromage NR, Cumaranatunga R. Egg production in the rainbow trout. Rec Adv Aquacul 3:65-138 (1988).
114. Clemens MJ. Regulation of egg protein synthesis by steroid hormones. Prog Biophys Molec Biol 28:71-108 (1978).
115. Fry DM, Toone CK. DDT-induced feminization of gull embryos. Science 213:922-924 (1981).
116. Fry DM, Toone CK, Speich SM, Peard RJ. Sex ratio skew and breeding patterns of gulls: demographic and toxicological considerations. Stud Avian Biol 10:26-43 (1987).
117. Hunt GLJ, Hunt MW. Female-female pairing in western gulls (Larus occidentalis) in southern California. Science 196:1466-1467 (1977).
118. Conover MR, Hunt GLJ. Female-female pairing and sex ratios in gulls: a historical perspective. Wilson Bull 96:619-625 (1984).
119. Subramanian A, Tanabe S, Tatsukawa R, Saito S, Miyazaki N. Reduction in the testosterone levels by PCBs and DDE in Dall's porpoises of the northwestern North Pacific. Mar Pollut Bull 18:643-646 (1987).
120. Freeman HC, Sangalang GB. A study of the effects of methyl mercury, cadmium, arsenic, selenium, and a PCB (Aroclor 1254) on adrenal and testicular steroidogenesis in vitro, by the grey seal Halachoerus grypus. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 5:369-383 (1977).
121. Brouwer A, Reijnders PJH, Koeman JH. Polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB)-contaminated fish induces vitamin A and thyroid hormone deficiency in the common seal (Phoca vitulina). Aquatic Toxicol 15:99-105 (1989).
122. Facemire CF, Gross TS, Guillette LJJ. Reproductive impairment in the Florida panther: nature or nurture. Environ Health Perspect 103(Suppl 4):79-86 (1995).
123. Roelke ME. Florida Panther Biomedical Investigations: Health and Reproduction. Final Report. Endangered Species Project E-1II-E-6 7506. Gainsville, FL:Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, 1990.
124. Bigler WJ, Jenkins JH, Cumbie PM, Hoff GL, Prather EC. Wildlife and environmental health: raccoons as indicators of zoonoses and pollutants in the Southeastern United States. J Am Vet Med Assoc 167:592-597 (1975).
125. Pelliniemi LJ, Dym M. The fetal gonad and sexual differentiation. In: Maternal-Fetal Endocrinology (Tulchinsky D, Little AB, eds). London:W.B.Saunders, 1994;297-320.
126. Foster JW, Dominguez-Steglich MA, Guioli S, Kwok C, Weller PA, Stevanovic M, Weissenbach J, Mansour S, Young ID, Goodfellow PN, Brook JD, Schafer AJ. Campomelic dysplasia and autosomal sex reversal caused by mutations in an SRY-related gene. Nature 372:525-530 (1994).
127. Ikeda Y, Shen W-H, Ingraham HA, Parker KL. Developmental expression of mouse steroidogenic factor-1, an essential regulator of the steroid hydroxylases. Mol Endocrinol 8:654-662 (1994).
128. Haqq CM, King C-Y, Ukiyama E, Falsafi S, Haqq TN, Donahoe PK, Weiss MA. Molecular basis of mammalian sexual determination: activation of Müllerian inhibiting substance gene expression by SRY. Science 266:1494-1500 (1994).
129. Scully RE. Neoplasia associated with anomalous sexual development and abnormal sex chromosomes. Pediatr Adolesc Endocrinol 8:203-217 (1981).
130. Savage MO, Lowe DG. Gonadal neoplasia and abnormal sexual differentiation. Clin Endocrinol 32:519-533 (1990).
131. Berkowitz GD. Abnormalities of gonadal determination and differentiation. Semin Perinatol 16:289-298 (1992).
132. Sell S, Pierce B. Maturation arrest of stem cell differentiation is a common pathway for the cellular origin of teratocarcinomas and epithelial cancers. Lab Invest 70:6-22 (1994).
133. Rajpert-De Meyts E, Skakkebæk NE. The possible role of sex hormones in the development of testicular cancer. Eur Urol 23:54-61 (1993).
134. Henderson BE, Bernstein L, Ross RK, Depue RH, Judd HL. The early in utero oestrogen and testosterone environment of blacks and whites: potential effects on male offspring. Br J Cancer 57:216-218 (1988).
135. Hutson JM, Ikawa H, Donahoe PK. Estrogen inhibition of Müllerian inhibiting substance in the chick embryo. J Pediatr Surg 17:953-959 (1982).
136. Newbold RR, Suzuki Y, McLachlan JA. Müllerian duct maintenance in heterotypic organ culture after in vivo exposure to diethylstilbestrol. Endocrinology 115:1863-1868 (1984).
137. Kuroda T, Lee MM, Ragin RC, Hirobe S, Donahoe PK. Müllerian inhibiting substance production and cleavage is modulated by gonadotropins and steroids. Endocrinology 129:2985-2992 (1991).
138. Sharpe RM. Regulation of spermatogenesis. In: The Physiology of Reproduction (Knobil E, Neill JD, eds). New York:Raven Press, 1994;1-72.
139. George FW, Wilson JD. Estrogen formation in the early rabbit embryos. Science 199:200-201 (1978).
140. Dickman Z, Day SK. Proceedings: Two theories: the preimplantation embryo is a source of steroid hormones controlling (1) morula-blastocyst transformation and (2) implantation. J Reprod Fertil 35:615-617 (1973).
141. Hou Q, Gorski J. Estrogen receptor and progesterone receptor genes are expressed differentially in mouse embryos during preimplantation development. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:9460-9464 (1993).
142. Greco TL, Furlow JD, Duello TM, Gorski J. Immunodetection of estrogen receptors in fetal and neonatal male mouse reproductive tracts. Endocrinology 130:421-429 (1992).
143. Greco TL, Duello TM, Gorski J. Estrogen receptors, estradiol, and diethylstilbestrol in early development: the mouse as a model for the study of estrogen receptors and estrogen sensitivity in embryonic development of male and female reproductive tracts. Endocr Rev 14:59-71 (1993).
144. Guerrier D, Boussin L, Mader S, Josso N, Kahn A, Picard J-Y. Expression of the gene for anti-Müllerian hormone. J Reprod Fertil 88:695-706 (1990).
145. Jost A, Vigier B, Prepin J, Perchellet JP. Studies on sex differentiation in mammals. Recent Prog Horm Res 29:1-41 (1973).
146. Lubahn DB, Moyer JS, Golding TS, Couse JF, Korach KS, Smithies O. Alteration of reproductive function but not prenatal sexual development after insertional disruption of the mouse estrogen receptor gene. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:11162-11166 (1993).
147. Smith EP, Boyd J, Frank GR, Takahashi H, Cohen RM, Specker B, Williams TC, Lubahn DB, Korach KS. Estrogen resistance caused by a mutation in the estrogen-receptor gene in a man. N Engl J Med 331:1056-1061 (1994).
148. Davis VL, Couse JF, Goulding EH, Power SGA, Eddy EM, Korach KS. Aberrant reproductive phenotypes evident in transgenic mice expressing the wild-type mouse estrogen receptor. Endocrinology 135:379-386 (1994).
149. Hertz R. The estrogen problem-retrospect and prospect. In: Estrogens in the Environment. II: Influences on Development (McLachlan JA, ed). New York:Elsevier, 1985;1-11.
150. Jabara AG. Some tissue changes in the dog following stilboestrol administration. Aust J Exp Biol 40:293-308 (1962).
151. Schwartz E, Tornaben JA, Boxill GC. Effects of chronic oral administration of a long-acting estrogen, quinestrol, to dogs. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 14:487-494 (1969).
152. Morrison AS. Cryptorchidism, hernia, and cancer of the testis. J Natl Cancer Inst 56:731-733 (1976).
153. Burns RK. Role of hormones in the differentiation of sex. In: Sex and Internal Secretions (Young WC, Corner GW, eds). Baltimore:Williams and Wilkins, 1961;76-160.
154. Teng CS, Teng CT. Studies on sex-organ development: ontogeny of cytoplasmic oestrogen receptor in chick mullerian duct. Biochem J 150:183-190 (1975).
155. Wibbels T, Bull JJ, Crews D. Synergism between temperature and estradiol: a common pathway. J Exp Zool 260:130-134 (1991).
156. Wibbels T, Bull JJ, Crews D. Chronology and morphology of temperature-dependent sex determination. J Exp Zool 260:371-381 (1991).
157. MacLaughlin DT, Hutson JM, Donahoe PK. Specific estradiol binding in embryonic mullerian ducts: a potential modulator of regression in the male and female chick. Endocrinology 113:141-145 (1983).
158. Teng CS. Quantitative change in fibronectin in cultured mullerian mesenchymal cells in response to diethylstilbestrol and mullerian-inhibiting substance. Dev Biol 140:1-7 (1990).
159. Orth JM, Gunsalus GL, Lamperti AA. Evidence from Sertoli cell-depleted rats indicates that spermatid number in adults depends on numbers of Sertoli cells produced during perinatal development. Endocrinology 122:787-794 (1988).
160. Russell LD, Peterson RN. Determination of the elongate spermatid-Sertoli cell ratio in various mammals. J Reprod Fertil 70:635-641 (1984).
161. Orth J. Proliferation of Sertoli cells in fetal and postnatal rats: a quantitative autoradiographic study. Anat Rec 203:485-492 (1982).
162. Orth JM. The role of follicle-stimulating hormone in controlling Sertoli cell proliferation in testes of fetal rats. Endocrinology 115:1248-1255 (1984).
163. Rey RA, Campo SM, Bedecarrás P, Nagle CA, Chemes HE. Is infancy a quiescent period of testicular development? Histological, morphometric, and functional study of the seminiferous tubules of the Cebus monkey from birth to the end of puberty. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 76:1325-1331 (1993).
164. Arai Y, Mori T, Suzuki Y, Bern HA. Long-term effects of perinatal exposure to sex steroids and diethylstilbestrol on the reproductive system of male mammals. Int Rev Cytol 84:235-268 (1983).
165. Thomas GB, McNeilly AS, Gibson F, Brooks AN. Effect of pituitary-gonadal suppression with a gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist on fetal gonadotrophin secretion, fetal gonadal development and maternal steroid secretion in the sheep. J Endocrinol 141:317-324 (1994).
166. Palmlund I, Apfel R, Buitendijk S, Cabau A, Forsberg J-G. Effects of diethylstilbestrol (DES) medication during pregnancy: report from a symposium at the 10th International Congress of ISPOG. J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol 14:71-89 (1993).
167. Dieckmann WJ, Davis ME, Rynkiewicz LM, Pottinger RE. Does administration of diethylstilbestrol during pregnancy have therapeutic value? Am J Obstet Gynecol 66:1062-1081 (1953).
168. Brackbill Y, Berendes HW. Dangers of diethylstilbestrol: review of a 1953 paper. Lancet 2:520 (1978).
169. Herbst AL, Scully RE. Adenocarcinoma of the vagina in adolescence: a report of seven cases including six clear cell carcinomas (so-called mesonephromas). Cancer 25:745-757 (1970).
170. Herbst AL, Ulfelder H, Poskanzer DC. Adenocarcinoma of the vagina. Association of maternal stilbestrol therapy with tumour appearance in young women. N Engl J Med 284:878-881 (1971).
171. Stillman RJ. In utero exposure to diethylstilbestrol: adverse effects on the reproductive tract and reproductive performance in male and female offspring. Am J Obstet Gynecol 142:905-921 (1982).
172. Henderson BE, Benton B, Cosgrove M, Baptista J, Aldrich J, Townsend D, Hart W, Mack TM. Urogenital tract abnormalities in sons of women treated with diethylstilbestrol. Pediatrics 58:505-507 (1976).
173. Gill WB, Schumacher GFB, Bibbo M. Pathological semen and anatomical abnormalities of the genital tract in human male subjects exposed to diethylstilbestrol in utero. J Urol 117:477-480 (1977).
174. Gill WB, Schumacher GFB, Bibbo M, Straus FHI, Schoenberg HW. Association of diethylstilbestrol exposure in utero with cryptorchidism, testicular hypoplasia and semen abnormalities. J Urol 122:36-39 (1979).
175. Wilcox AJ, Baird DD, Weinberg CR, Hornsby PP, Herbst AL. Fertility in men exposed prenatally to diethylstilbestrol. N Engl J Med 332:1411-1416 (1995).
176. Stenchever MA, Williamson RA, Leonard J, Karp LE, Ley B, Shy K, Smith D. Possible relationship between in utero diethylstilbestrol exposure and male fertility. Am J Obstet Gynecol 140:186-193 (1981).
177. Whitehead ED, Leiter E. Genital abnormalities and abnormal semen analyses in male patients exposed to diethylstilbestrol in utero. J Urol 125:47-50 (1981).
178. Driscoll SG, Taylor SH. Effects of prenatal maternal estrogen on the male urogenital system. Obstet Gynecol 56:537-542 (1980).
179. Raman-Wilms L, Tseng AL-i, Wighardt S, Einarson TR, Koren G. Fetal genital effects of first-trimester sex hormone exposure: a metaanalysis. Obstet Gynecol 85:141-149 (1995).
180. Beard M, Melton LJ, O'Fallon WM, Noller KL, Benson RC. Cryptorchism and maternal estrogen exposure. Am J Epidemiol 120:707-716 (1984).
181. Gill WB, Schumacher GFB, Bibbo M. Genital and semen abnormalities in adults males two and one-half decades after in utero exposure to diethylstilbestrol. In: Intrauterine Exposure to Diethylstilbestrol in the Human (Herbst AL, ed). Chicago: American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 1978.
182. Schumacher GFB, Gill WB, Hubby MM, Bluogh RR. Semen analysis in males exposed in utero to diethylstilbestrol (DES) or placebo. Reprod Obstet Gynecol 9:100-101 (1981).
183. Andonian RW, Kessler R. Transplacental exposure to diethylstilbestrol in men. Urology 13:276-279 (1976).
184. Vessey MP. Epidemiological studies of the effects of diethylstilbestrol. IARC Sci Publ 96:335-348 (1989).
185. Conley GR, Sant GR, Ucci AA, Mitcheson HD. Seminoma and epididymal cysts in a young man with known diethylstilbestrol exposure in utero. JAMA 249:1325-1326 (1983).
186. Henderson BE, Benton B, Jing J, Yu MC, Pike MC. Risk factors for cancer of the testis in young men. Int J Cancer 23:598-602 (1979).
187. Depue RH, Pike MC, Henderson BE. Estrogen exposure during gestation and risk of testicular cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 71:1151-1155 (1983).
188. Schottenfeld D, Warshauer ME, Sherlock S, Zauber AG, Leder M, Payne R. The epidemiology of testicular cancer in young adults. Am J Epidemiol 112:232-246 (1980).
189. Brown LM, Pottern LM, Hoover RN. Prenatal and perinatal risk factors for testicular cancer. Cancer Res 46:4812-4816 (1986).
190. Moss AR, Osmond D, Bacchetti P, Torti FM, Gurgin V. Hormonal risk factors in testicular cancer. A case-control study. Am J Epidemiol 124:39-52 (1986).
191. Gershman ST, Stolley PD. A case-control study of testicular cancer using Connecticut tumour registry data. Int J Epidemiol 17:738-742 (1988).
192. McLachlan JA. Rodent models for perinatal exposure to diethylstilbestrol and their relation to human disease in the male. In: Developmental Effects of Diethylstilbestrol (DES) in Pregnancy (Herbst AL, Bern HA, eds). New York: Thieme-Stratton, 1981;148-157.
193. Newbold RR, McLachlan JA. Diethylstilbestrol associated defects in murine genital tract development. In: Estrogens in the Environment. II: Influences on Development (McLachlan JA, ed). New York:Elsevier, 1985;288-318.
194. Song W, Moore R, McLachlan JA, Negishi M. Molecular characterization of a testis-specific estrogen sulfotransferase and aberrant liver expression in obese and diabetogenic C57BL/KsJ-db/db mice. Endocrinology 136:2477-2484 (1995).
195. Brown-Grant K, Fink G, Greig F, Murray MAF. Altered sexual development in male rats after oestrogen administration during the neonatal period. J Reprod Fertil 44:25-42 (1975).
196. Ohta Y. Response of testis to androgen and gonadotropins in neonatally estrogenized and androgenized mice. Endocrinol Jpn 24:287-294 (1977).
197. Walker AH, Bernstein L, Warren DW, Warner NE, Zheng X, Henderson BE. The effect of in utero ethinyl oestradiol exposure on the risk of cryptorchid testis and testicular teratoma in mice. Br J Cancer 62:599-602 (1990).
198. Newbold RR, Bullock BC, McLachlan JA. Adenocarcinoma of the rete testis. Diethylstilbestrol-induced lesions of the mouse rete testis. Am J Pathol 125:625-628 (1986).
199. Sharpe RM. Falling sperm counts in men--is there an endocrine cause? J Endocrinol 137:357-360 (1993).
200. Sharpe RM, Fisher JS, Millar MM, Jobling S, Sumpter JP. Gestational and lactational exposure of rats to xenoestrogens results in reduced testicular size and sperm production. Environ Health Perspect 103:1136-1143 (1995).
201. Sharman M, Read WA, Castle L, Gilbert J. Levels of di-(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate and total phthalate esters in milk, cream, butter and cheese. Food Add Contam 11:375-385 (1994).
202. Soto AM, Justicia H, Wray JW, Sonnenschein C. p-Nonylphenol an estrogenic xenobiotic released from "modified" polystyrene. Environ Health Perspect 92:167-173 (1991).
203. Jobling S, Reynolds T, White R, Parker MG, Sumpter JP. A variety of environmentally persistent chemicals, including some phthalate plasticizers, are weakly estrogenic. Environ Health Perspect 103:582-587 (1995).
204. Soto AM, Sonnenschein C, Chung KL, Fernandez MF, Olea N, Olea Serrano F. The E-SCREEN assay as a tool to identify estrogens: an update on estrogenic environmental pollutants. Environ Health Perspect 103(Suppl 3):113-122 (1995).
205. McDonnell DP, Clemm DL, Hermann T, Goldman ME, Pike JW. Analysis of Estrogen receptor function in vitro reveals three distinct classes of antiestrogens. Mol Endocrinol 9:659-669 (1995).
206. Thomas KB, Colborn T. Organochlorine endocrine disrupters in human tissue. In: Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:365-394 (1992).
207. Calabrese EJ. Human breast milk contamination in the United States and Canada by chlorinated hydrocarbon insecticides and industrial pollutants: current status. J Am College Toxicol 1:91-98 (1982).
208. Norstrom RJ, Simon M, Muir DCG, Schweinsburg RE. Organochlorine contaminants in arctic marine food chains: identification, geographical distribution, and temporal trends in polar bears. Environ Sci Technol 22:1063-1071 (1988).
209. Bitman J, Cecil HC. Estrogenic activity of DDT analogs and polychlorinated biphenyls. Agr Food Chem 18:1108-1112 (1970).
210. Lamont TG, Bagley GE, Reichel WL. Residues of o,p´-DDD and o,p´-DDT in brown pelican eggs and mallard ducks. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 5:231-236 (1970).
211. Bustos S, Denegri JC, Diaz F, Tchernitchin AN. p,p´-DDT is an estrogenic compound. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 41:496-501 (1988).
212. Soto AM, Lin T-M, Justicia H, Silvia RM, Sonnenschein C. An "in culture" bioassay to assess the estrogenicity of xenobiotics (E-SCREEN). In: Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:295-309 (1992).
213. Sharpe RM. Another DDT connection. Nature 375:538-539 (1995).
214. Kelce WR, Stone CR, Laws SC, Gray LEJ, Kemppainen JA, Wilson EM. Persistent DDT metabolite, p,p´-DDE is a potent androgen receptor antagonist. Nature 375:581-585 (1995).
215. Smith AG. Chlorinated hydrocarbon insecticides. In: Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology (Hayes WJ, Laws ER, eds). New York:Academic Press, 1991;731-915.
216. Bulger WH, Muccitelli RM, Kupfer K. Studies on the in vivo and in vitro estrogenic activities of methoxychlor and its metabolites. Role of hepatic mono-oxygenase in methoxychlor activation. Biochem Pharmacol 27:2417-2423 (1978).
217. Gellert RJ, Heinrichs WL, Swerdloff R. Effects of neonatally administered DDT homologs on reproductive function in male and female rats. Neuroendocrinology 16:84-94 (1974).
218. Gellert RJ, Wilson C. Reproductive function in rats exposed prenatally to pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB). Environ Res 18:437-443 (1979).
219. Gray LEJ, Ostby J, Ferrell J, Rehnberg G, Linder R, Cooper R, Goldman J, Slott V, Laskey J. A dose-response analysis of methoxychlor-induced alterations of reproductive development and function in the rat. Fundam Appl Toxicol 12:92-108 (1989).
220. Gray LEJ. Chemical-induced alterations of sexual differentiation: a review of effects in humans and rodents. In: Chemically induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:203-230 (1992).
221. Haake J, Kelley M, Keys B, Safe S. The effects of organochlorine pesticides as inducers of testosterone and benzo[a]pyrene hydroxylases. Gen Pharmac 18:165-169 (1987).
222. Balash KJ, Al-Omar MA, Latif BMA. Effect of chlordane on testicular tissues of Swiss mice. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 39:434-442 (1987).
223. ATSDR. Toxicological Profile for Aldrin/Dieldrin. Atlanta:Association for Toxic Substances and Drug Research, 1987.
224. Arnold DL, Moodie CA, Charbonneau SM, Grice HC, McGuire PF, Bryce FR, Collins BT, Zawidzka ZZ, Krewski DR, Nera EA, Munro IC. Long-term toxicity of hexachlorobenzene in the rat and the effect of dietary vitamin A. Food Chem Toxicol 23:779-793 (1985).
225. Jensen AA, Slorach SA. Chemical Contaminants in Human Milk. Boston:CRC Press, 1991.
226. Cooper RL, Chadwick RW, Rehnberg GL, Goldman JM, Booth KC, Hein JF, McElroy WK. Effect of lindane on hormonal control of reproductive function in the female rat. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 99:384-394 (1989).
227. Van Velsen FL, Danse LHJC, Van Leeuwen FXR, Dormans JAMA, Van Logten MJ. The subchronic oral toxicity of the B-isomer of hexachlorocyclohexane in rats. Fundam Appl Toxicol 6:697-712 (1986).
228. Gray LEJ. Neonatal chlordecone exposure alters behavioral sex differentiation in female hamsters. Neuroendocrinol 3:67-80 (1982).
229. Hammond B, Katzenellenbogen B, Krauthammer N, McConnel J. Estrogenic activity of the insecticide chlordecone (Kepone) and interaction with uterine estrogen receptors. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 76:6641-6645 (1979).
230. Palmiter RD, Mulvihill ER. Estrogenic activity of the insecticide kepone on the chicken oviduct. Science 201:356-358 (1978).
231. Safe SH. Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDDs), dibenzofurans (PCDFs), and related compounds: environmental and mechanistic considerations which support the development of toxic equivalency factors (TEFs). Crit Rev Toxicol 21:51-88 (1990).
232. Ahlborg UG, Hanberg A, Kenne K. Risk assessment of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Nord 1992:26. Copenhagen:Nordic Council of Ministers, 1992.
233. Krishnan V, Safe S. Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDDs), and dibenzofurans (PCDFs) as antiestrogens in MCF-7 human breast cancer cells: quantitative structure-activity relationships. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 120:55-61 (1993).
234. Lilienthal H, Winneke G. Sensitive periods for behavioral toxicity of polychlorinated biphenyls: determination by cross-fostering in rats. Fundam Appl Toxicol 17:368-375 (1991).
235. Korach KS, Sarver P, Chae K, McLachlan JA, McKinney JD. Estrogen receptor-binding activity of polychlorinated hydrobiphenyls conformationally restricted structural probes. Mol Pharmacol 33:130-126 (1988).
236. Reijnders PJH. Reproductive failure in common seals feeding on fish from polluted coastal waters. Nature 324:456-457 (1986).
237. Safe SH. Comparative toxicology and mechanism of action of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 26:371-399 (1986).
238. Skene SA, Dewhurst IC, Greenberg M. Polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and polychlorinated dibenzofurans: the risk to human health. A review. Hum Toxicol 8:173-203 (1989).
239. Peterson RE, Theobald HM, Kimmel GL. Developmental and reproductive toxicity of dioxins and related compounds: cross-species comparisons. Crit Rev Toxicol 23:283-335 (1993).
240. Safe S, Astroff B, Harris M, Zacharewski T, Romkes M, Biegel L. 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) and related compounds as antioestrogens: characterization and mechanism of action. Pharmacol Toxicol 69:400-409 (1991).
241. Lucier GW, Portier CJ, Gallo MA. Receptor mechanisms and dose-response models for the effects of dioxins. Environ Health Perspect 101:36-44 (1993).
242. Peterson RE, Moore RW, Mably TA, Bjerke DL, Goy RW. Male reproductive system ontogeny: effect of perinatal exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. In: Chemically-induced Alterations in Sexual and Functional Development: The Wildlife/Human Connection (Colborn T, Clement C, eds). Adv Mod Environ Toxicol 21:175-94 (1992).
243. Mably TA, Moore RW, Bjerke DL, Peterson RE. The male reproductive system is highly sensitive to in utero and lactational TCDD exposure. In: Biological Basis for Risk Assessment of Dioxins and Related Compounds (Gallo MA, Scheuplein RJ, van der Heijden CA, eds). New York:Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, 1991;69-78.
244. Mably TA, Bjerke DL, Moore RW, Gendron-Fitzpatrick A, Peterson RE. In utero and lactational exposure of male rats to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. 3: Effects on spermatogenesis and reproductive capability. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 114:118-126 (1992).
245. Mably TA, Moore RW, Goy RW, Peterson RE. In utero and lactational exposure of male rats to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. 2: Effects on sexual behaviour and the regulation of luteinizing hormone secretion in adulthood. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 114:108-117 (1992).
246. Mably TA, Moore RW, Peterson RE. In utero and lactational exposure of male rats to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. 1. Effects on androgenic status. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 114:97-107 (1992).
247. Bowman RE, Schantz SL, Weerasinghe NCA, Gross ML, Barsotti DA. Chronic dietary intake of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) at 5 or 25 parts per trillion in the monkey: TCDD kinetics and dose-effect estimate of reproductive toxicity. Chemosphere 18:243-252 (1989).
248. ECETOC. Exposure of Man to Dioxins: A Perspective on Industrial Waste Incineration. Technical Report No 49. Brussels:European Centre for Ecotoxicology and Toxicology of Chemicals, 1992.
249. Ahel M, Conrad J, Giger W. Persistent organic chemicals in sewage effluents. 3: Determination of nonylphenoxy carboxylic acids by high resolution gas chromatography. Environ Sci Technol 21:697, (1987).
250. Ahel M, Giger W, Koch M. Behaviour of alkylphenol polyethoxylate surfactants in the aquatic environment. I: Occurrence and transformation in sewage treatment. Water Res 28:1131-1142 (1994).
251. Ahel M, Giger W, Schaffner C. Behaviour of alkylphenol polyethoxylate surfactants in the aquatic environment. II: Occurrence and transformation in rivers. Water Res 28:1143-1152 (1994).
252. Giger W, Brunner PH, Schaffner C. 4-Nonylphenol in sewage sludge: accumulation of toxic from nonionic surfactants. Science 225:623-625 (1984).
253. Holt MS, Mitchell GC, Watkinson RJ. The environmental chemistry, fate, and effects of nonionic surfactants. In: The Handbook of Environmental Chemistry. Vol 3, Part F (Hutzinger O, ed). Berlin:Springer-Verlag, 1992; 89-144.
254. Naylor GC, Mierure JP, Weeks JA, Castaldi RJ, Romano RR. Alkylphenol ethoxylates in the environment. J Am Oil Chem Soc 69:695-703 (1992).
255. Ekelund R, Bergman A, Granmo A, Berggren M. Bioaccumulation of 4-nonylphenol in marine animals. A re-evaluation. Environ Pollut 64:107-120 (1990).
256. Ahel M, McEvoy J, Giger W. Bioaccumulation of the lipophilic metabolites of nonionic surfactants in freshwater organisms. Environ Pollut 79:243-248 (1993).
257. White R, Jobling S, Hoare SA, Sumpter JP, Parker MG. Environmentally persistent alkylphenolic compounds are estrogenic. Endocrinology 135:175-182 (1994).
258. Verdeal K, Ryan S. Naturally occurring estrogens in plant foodstuff--a review. J Food Prot 42:577-583 (1979).
259. Bradbury RB, White DE. Oestrogens and related substances in plants. Vitamins, Hormones 12:207-233 (1954).
260. Adlercreutz H, van der Wildt J, Kinzel J, Attalla H, Wähälä K, Mäkelä T, Hase T, Fotsis T. Lignan and isoflavonoid conjugates in human urine. J Steroid Biochem 52:97-103 (1995).
261. Verdeal K, Ryan DS. Naturally-occurring oestrogens in plant foodstuffs--a review. J Food Protect 7:577-583 (1979).
262. Price KR, Fenwick GR. Naturally occurring oestrogens in foods--a review. Food Add Contam 2:73-106 (1985).
263. Kaldas RS, Hughes GL. Reproductive and general metabolic effects of phytoestrogens in mammals. Reprod Toxicol Rev 3:81-89 (1989).
264. Shutt DA. The effects of plant estrogens on animal reproduction. Endeavour 35:110-113 (1976).
265. Setchell KDR, Borriello SP, Hulme P, Krik DN, Axelson M. Nonsteroidal estrogens of dietary origin: possible roles in hormone-dependent disease. Am J Clin Nutr 40:569-578 (1992).
266. Cassidy A, Bingham S, Setchell K. Biological effects of a diet of soy protein rich in isoflavones on the menstrual cycle of premenopausal women. Am J Clin Nutr 60:333-340 (1994).
267. Krishnan AV, Stathis P, Permuth SF, Tokes L, Feldman D. Bisphenol-A: an estrogenic substance is released from polycarbonate flasks during autoclaving. Endocrinology 132:2279-2286 (1993).
268. Brotons JA, Olea-Serrano MF, Villalobos M, Pedraza V, Olea N. Xenoestrogens released from lacquer coatings in food cans. Environ Health Perspect 103:608-612 (1995).
269. Hansen E, Meyer O. Animal models in reproductive toxicology. In: Handbook of Laboratory Animals Science. Vol II: Animal Models (Svendsen P, Hau J, eds). Boca Raton, FL:CRC Press, 1994.
270. McLachlan JA, Korach KS, Newbold RR, Degen GH. Diethylstilbestrol and other estrogens in the environment. Fundam Appl Toxicol 4:686-691 (1984).
271. Grosvenor CE, Picciano MF, Baumrucker CR. Hormones and growth factors in milk. Endocr Rev 14:710-728 (1992).
272. Shore LS, Gurevitz M, Shemesh M. Estrogen as an environmental pollutant. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 51:361-366 (1993).
273. Guzelian PS. Comparative toxicology of chlordecone (Kepone) in humans and experimental animals. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 22:89-113 (1982).
274. Fein GG, Jacobson JL, Jacobson SW, Schwartz PM, Dowler JK. Prenatal exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls. Effects on birth size and gestational age. J Pediatr 105:315-320 (1984).
275. Jacobson SW, Fein GG, Jacobson JL, Schwarz PM, Dowler JK. The effects of PCB exposure on visual recognition memory. Child Dev 56:853-860 (1985).
276. Jacobson JL, Jacobson SW. New methodologies for assessing the effects of prenatal toxic exposure on cognitive functioning in humans. In: Toxic Contaminants and Ecosystem Health: A Great Lakes Focus (Evans M, ed). New York:John Wiley and Sons, 1988;374-388.
277. Jacobson JL, Jacobson SW, Humphrey HEB. Effects of exposure to PCBs and related compounds on growth and activity in children. Neurotox Terat 12:319-326 (1990).
278. Jacobson JL, Jacobson SW, Humprey HEB. Effects of in utero exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and other contaminants on cognitive functioning in young children. J Pediatr 116:38-45 (1990).
279. Bush B, Bennett A, Snow J. Polychlorinated biphenyl congeners, p,p´-DDE, and sperm function in humans. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 15:333-341 (1986).
280. Lione A. Polychlorinated biphenyls and reproduction. Reprod Toxicol Rev 2:83-89 (1988).
281. Guo YL, Lai TJ, Ju SH, Chen YC, Hsu CC. Sexual developments in biological findings in Yucheng children. DIOXIN '93: 13th International Symposium on Chlorinated Dioxins and Related Compounds 14:235-238 (1993).
282. Jensen AA. PCBs, PDDs, PCDFs in human milk and blood and adipose tissue. Sci Tot Environ 64:259-293 (1987).
283. Kimbrough RD. How toxic is 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzodioxin to humans? J Toxicol Environ Health 30:261-271 (1990).
284. Bertazzi PA, Zochetti C, Pesatori AC, Guercilena S, Sanarico M, Radice L. Ten-year mortality study of the population involved in the Seveso incident in 1976. Am J Epidemiol 129:1187-1200 (1989).
285. WHO. Polychlorinated Dibenzo-para-dioxins and Dibenzofurans. Environ Health Criteria 88. Geneva:World Health Organization, 1989.
286. Clark LB, Rosen RT, Hartman TG, Louis JB, Suffet IH, Lippincott RL, Rosen JD. Determination of alkylphenol ethoxylates and their acetic acid derivatives in drinking water by particle beam liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry. Int J Environ Anal Chem 47:167-180 (1992).
287. Cassidy A, Bingham S, Carlson J, Setchell KDR. Biological effects of plant estrogens in premenopausal women. FASEB J 7:A866 (1993).
288. Baird DD, Umbach DM, Lansdell L, Hughes CL, Setchell KDR, Weinberg CR, Haney AF, Wilcox AJ, McLachlan JA. Dietary intervention study to assess estrogenicity of dietary soy among postmenopausal women. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 80:1685-1690 (1995).
289. Wilcox G, Wahlqvist ML, Burger HG, Medley G. Oestrogenic effects of plant foods in postmenopausal women. Br Med J 301:905-906 (1990).
290. Clarkson TB, Anthony MS, Hughes CLJ. Estrogenic soybean isoflavones and chronic disease: risks and benefits. Trends Endocrinol Metab 6:11-19 (1995).
291. Bibbo M, Gill WB, Azizi F, Bluogh R, Fang VS, Rosenfield RL, Schumacher GFB, Sleeper K, Sonek MG, Wied GL. Follow-up study of male and female offspring of DES-exposed mothers. Obstet Gynecol 49:1-8 (1977).
292. Adlercreutz H. Diet, breast cancer and sex hormone metabolism. Ann N Y Acad Sci 595:281-290 (1990).
293. de Cock J, Westveer K, Heederik D, te Velde E, van Kooij R. Time to pregnancy and occupational exposure to pesticides in fruit growers in The Netherlands. Occup Environ Med 51:693-699 (1994).
294. Fox GA. Practical causal inference for ecoepidemiologists. J Toxicol Environ Health 33:359-373 (1991).
295. Lan NC, Katzenellenbogen BS. Temporal relationships between hormone receptor binding and biological responses in the uterus: studies with short- and long-acting derivatives of estradiol. Endocrinology 98:220-227 (1976).
296. Moore HDM, Thurstan SM. Sexual differentiation in the gray-tailed opossum, Monodelphis domestica, and the effects of oestradiol on testis development. J Zool 221:639-658 (1990).
297. Sumpter JP, Jobling S. Vitellogenesis as a biomarker for estrogenic contamination of the aquatic environment. Environ Health Perspect 103(Suppl 7):173-178 (1995).
298. Copeland PA, Sumpter JP, Walker JP, Croft M. Vitellogenin levels in male and female rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) at various stages of the reproductive cycle. Comp Biochem Physiol 83B:487-493 (1986).
299. Bulger WH, Kupfer D. Estrogenic action of DDT analogs. Am J Ind Med 4:163-173 (1983).
300. Maitre JI, Mercier L, Dolo L, Valotaire Y. Characterization of estradiol specific receptors and induction of vitellogenin and vitellogenin mRNA in the rainbow trout liver (Salmo gairneri). Biochimie 67:215-225 (1985).
301. Sumpter JP. The purification, radioimmunoassay and plasma levels of vitellogenin from the rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri). In: Trends in Comparative Endocrinology (Lofts B, Holmes WH, eds). Hong Kong:Hong Kong University Press, 1985;355-357.
302. Vaillant C, Le Guellec C, Pakdel F, Valotaire Y. Vitellogenin gene expression in primary culture of male rainbow trout hepatocytes. Gen Comp Endocrinol 70:284-290 (1988).
303. Klein KO, Baron J, Colli MJ, McDonnell DP, Cutler GBJ. Estrogen levels in childhood determined by an ultrasensitive recombinant cell bioassay. J Clin Invest 94:2475-2480 (1994).
304. De Peretti E, Forest MG. Unconjugated dehydroepiandtrosterone plasma levels in normal subjects from birth to adolescence in human: the use of a sensitive radioimmunoassay. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 43:982 (1976).
305. Korenman SG, Stevens RH, Carpenter LA, Robb M, Niswender GD, Sherman BM. Estradiol radioimmunoassay without chromatography: procedure, validation and normal values. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 38:718-720 (1974).
306. Legan SJ, Karsch FJ, Foster DL. The endocrine control of seasonal reproductive function in ewe: a marked change in response to the negative feedback action of estradiol on luteinizing hormone secretion. Endocrinology 101:818-824 (1977).
307. Soto AM, Sonnenschein C. The role of estrogens on the proliferation of human breast cancer cells (MCF-7). J Steroid Biochem 23:87-94 (1985).
308. Thomas JA. Toxic responses of the reproductive system. In: Casarett and Doull's Toxicology: The Basic Science of Poisons (Amdur MO, Doull J, Klaassen CD, eds). New York: Pergamon Press, 1991;484-520.
309. Matzuk MM, Finegold MJ, Su J-GJ, Hsueh AJW, Bradley A. *-Inhibin is a tumour-suppressor gene with gonadal specificity in mice. Nature 360:313-319 (1992).
310. Hofmann MC, Narisawa S, Hess RA, Millán JL. Immortalization of germ cells and somatic testicular cells using the SV40 large antigen. Exp Cell Res 201:417-435 (1992).
311. Hofmann MC, Hess RA, Goldberg E, Millán JL. Immortalized germ cells undergo meiosis in vitro. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91:5533-5537 (1994).
312. Brinster RL, Avarbock MR. Germline transmission of donor haplotype following spermatogonial transplantation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91:11303-11307 (1994).
313. Brinster RL, Zimmermann JW. Spermatogenesis following male germ-cell transplantation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91:11298-11302 (1994).
314. Toppari J, Eerola E, Parvinen M. Flow cytometric DNA analysis of defined stages of rat seminiferous epithelial cycle during in vitro differentiation. J Androl 6:325-333 (1985).
315. Toppari J, Parvinen M. In vitro differentiation of rat seminiferous tubular segments from defined stages of the epithelial cycle: morphologic and immunolocalization analysis. J Androl 6:334-343 (1985).
316. Toppari, J. Rat spermatogenesis in vitro. Studies on differentiation of seminiferous tubule segments at defined stages of the epithelial cycle. PhD dissertation:University of Turku, Turku, Finland 1986.
317. Dodds EC, Lawson W. Molecular structure in relation to oestrogenic activity. Compounds without phenanthrene nucleus. Proc Royal Soc London 118(Series B):222-232 (1938).
318. UICC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 1. A Technical Report (Doll R, Payne P, Waterhouse J, eds). Geneva:International Union Against Cancer (Distributed by Springer Verlag, Berlin), 1966.
319. UICC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 2 (Doll R, Muir CS, Waterhouse JAH, eds). Geneva:International Union Against Cancer, 1970.
320. IARC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 3 (Waterhouse J, Muir C, Correa P, Powell J, eds). IARC Scientific Publ No 15. Lyon:International Agency for Research on Cancer, 1976.
321. IARC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 4 (Waterhouse J, Muir C, Shanmugaratnam K, Powell J, eds). IARC Scientific Publ No 42. Lyon:International Agency for Research on Cancer, 1982.
322. IARC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 5 (Muir C, Waterhouse J, Mack T, Powell J, Whelan S, eds). IARC Scientific Publ No 88. Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer, 1987.
323. IARC. Cancer Incidence in Five Continents, Vol 6 (Parkin DM, Muir CS, Whelan SL, Gao YT, Ferlay J, Powell J, eds). IARC Scientific Publ No 120. Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer, 1992.
Last Update: March 31, 1998
Table 1.
Table 1. Continued
Table 1. Continued
Table 1. Continued
